X.KOJIRA.IO
Timeline

fiatjaf

[email protected]
npub180cvv07tjdrrgpa0j7j7tmnyl2yr6yr7l8j4s3evf6u64th6gkwsyjh6w6
boa idéia, já que eu também tinha pensado
Nostr was proposed as a way to create a global public square, but after way too many years I realized this can't be its initial driving force, only the final outcome of multiple different driving forces.

An analogy that came to my mind is that in order to have a true public square we have to have all the houses and buildings around it. What we have on Nostr now is like a bunch of people sleeping on the streets, in a town with no houses.

So if we want Nostr to not just linger and die we have to start building the houses.

First, take all these people who are currently on the streets and put them into a big house with glass walls called wss://relay.primal.net + wss://nos.lol. Then create new buildings, by which of course I mean other relays with different rules and made for different people.

It will probably not work to just launch new relays and hope people will come using the same Nostr apps we currently use. It also doesn't make any sense to do what I and almost everybody else have done in the past 4 years and try to market this only to the people inside Nostr.

I think the idea is to just market your new vibecoded app as a gateway to one specific relay-based niche platform, or as a way to create your own relay-based community. This stuff has to be initially separate from "the current Nostr" community -- i.e. no "fallback relays", no "trending", no "global search", but if your new vibecoded app allows browsing different houses you can just frame "the current Nostr" as one of these.

The current apps we have are very amazing, with all their outboxes and threaded feeds and multi-kind support, and it is sad that only a small part of the world can experiment with them for now. But because they are optimized for the public square they should probably be paused and deemphasized for a while we don't have at least 3 other solid buildings in the Nostr town.

I don't know what I'm saying anymore, just wanted to leave this here.
Did I say that?

I think maybe what I was trying to say is that it needed to be more used so small and big issues were uncovered and fixed according to real world usage, but I don't know.

I wouldn't recommend that you just keep developing it alone every day for 3 months without it being used concretely in the real world.
I don't know, could have been any other character, it's a convention.
I read this note and https://github.com/nostr-protocol/nips/issues/2500, which I assume are related.

I'm still confused about what you're proposing. What is the basic idea in one sentence?

(It doesn't help that I can't see the note you're replying to, and I'm not sure I want to do that.)
No. But are you looking for purely an overlay network on top of the current internet or a new internet? FIPS was interesting to me because it at least claimed to be for replacing the current internet (by which I mean it is supposed to work on top of physical links), although now I see people treating it just as an overlay network like Tor, which is sad.

I had this idea a long time ago of how to connect and route between mesh networks potentially scaling through the entire globe, but I'm thinking here only about physical links and a new internet: nostr:naddr1qqyr2wpjvd3kgvtyqyghwumn8ghj7enfv96x5ctx9e3k7mgzyqalp33lewf5vdq847t6te0wvnags0gs0mu72kz8938tn24wlfze6qcyqqq823c53smcd

I have no idea of how bad this idea is, because I couldn't find anyone to criticize it or any other idea to compare it to and I have zero experience with any of this.

As far as I know all the mesh networks in the world are sadly much less ambitious than I want: they're all happy to just be a local thing. And in some cases they clearly state that their routing algorithms don't scale at all (they're either based on a centralized supernode, or nodes flooding the network with packets, or on everybody keeping a routing table of the entire network locally).

Projects like Meshtastic are just a stupid psyop. They get people to be excited about a completely useless thing, thinking they are contributing to creating a new decentralized internet, and that their stupid toy is actually a step towards that, but in fact it can never be more than that toy.

What I wanted to see was an actual meshnet project that employed some routing algorithm capable of easily adapting to new nodes joining freely, but also adapting to a new mesh network being connected by some new node, and then some other mesh connects to that, and so on, until you're able to route a message to someone a thousand miles away.

I think my method above works, and it is not magic because it has this important tradeoff: you can't route only with keys, i.e. your address can't be just your key like all these other projects do, you also need route hints in the address. It's like using an nprofile instead of an npub.

My method needs a lot of flushing, though. All the details are unspecified. And it would probably not work with any existing base network software, as it wouldn't deal with IP addresses at all (addresses would be much bigger than even IPv6 can support). It also needs a name, then we would have to adapt TCP and UDP to work on top of it (the name is important so we can call it TCP/<name> thing). I also didn't think about the incentives for routing at all.
And they say we don't have enough addictive content.

nevent1qvzqqqqqqyp…
Are you saying that some people decide to fund and encourage stupid projects that waste millions of hours of time of thousands of people who could otherwise be working in actual competitors to these incumbents?

That makes a lot of sense and I believe this stuff happens indeed, but I was trying to think of an example of this when I realized it would lead to the conclusion that Nostr itself is a psyop.
People making new apps, why aren't you adding Pomegranate support?

1) I didn't know it existed (now you know);
2) I think it has a fatal flaw (please say what is it);
3) I am phisophically opposed to Google (Pomegranate supports other providers, and even no providers at all, it can even be made to support phone numbers, a single password, an email, a set of friends' keys, you name it, but none of that is active yet because there is not enough interest);
4) I think users have to be trained to type private keys everywhere;
5) I like Amber (I've heard this one before so I included it here even though it makes no sense).

nevent1qvzqqqqqqyp…
I have the impression that these people are deeply unserious, they are just trying to make something cool that works on their playground.

Maybe it is my fault, but my impression is that they sell IPFS, FIPS or Yggdrasil as world-changing technologies that could replace the centralized mainstream things we currently have, even if it's a long shot.

For a while, I believed, and I think most people believe otherwise they wouldn't be investing their time in these things. But the creators probably don't care about the long term.

It's the same with Nostr, by the way. Nostr can work just fine with a billion people, that was the most important thing about it. Meanwhile it's clear, obvious if you think for more than 5 minutes that stuff like Mastodon and Bluesky can't, yet people are investing in these things as if they can.

It was naïve of me to think that most people interested in these things want to actually improve the world communication and were just misguided or dumb, it's more likely that they just don't care.
Do we have any reason to believe spanning trees will scale to more than a few thousand users? I don't think they even claim that.

In any case, DHTs have a much easier task if they're storing one address for each node in the network. On IPFS it would be an address for each file (or worse if they're chunked). It cannot work.

I wish they put more effort in explaining how their routing stuff works, since that is really the only thing that matters. The last time I checked they had this thing called "bitswap" that in practice meant that every node was at all times sending a bazillion messages to every other node announcing what files they had, meanwhile I couldn't send a file between two computers in the same LAN even after I manually told one to connect to the other with an IP address and node pubkey. It was ridiculous.
nostr:naddr1qqyxywr9xfnrjdfeqyghwumn8ghj7enfv96x5ctx9e3k7mgzyqalp33lewf5vdq847t6te0wvnags0gs0mu72kz8938tn24wlfze6qcyqqq823c7hkr3c
If you install nak from AUR you get free completions installed now.

I don't know why it took me so long to realize this would be possible and useful.

If you install it via other means, https://github.com/fiatjaf/nak has instructions on how to install completions now (a single line).

Also:

- `nak relays` command that lists write or read relays from anyone so you can use it on other commands.
- petname resolution: any place that would have otherwise taken a npub/hex pubkey/nprofile/nip05 now also takes a petname path like: "~/petname/petname-of-petname/..." (based on the current user --sec, if available) or "~dergigi.com/petname-of-gigi's-friend/..." based on absolute keys (also works with absolute npubs, but at this point you're not gaining much).
- `nak blossom upload --auto` uploads to your announced blossom servers.
- `nak podcast` fixes and improvements, `nak group chat` fixes and improvements (and many other fixes from npub1937vv2nf06360…).
- other small things no one cares.

By the way, I forgot that we had these commands, so maybe you'll want to know too:

- `nak git history`: display the history of commits from a GRASP repository
- `nak git ls`: list files in a directory of a GRASP repository
- `nak git download`: downloads a specific file from a GRASP repository
I'm working on a new operating system for Nostr, it's called Verdana (a tribute to the famous Slovenian alpine ski racer Ana Drev).

Just kidding, it's only a program. But the idea is that you install a bunch of very micro apps that do one thing only and compose your own client, in a way, by combining them. They are web apps and run in webviews, each in its own independent window, but they have access to a common database, a centralized engine that fetches feeds of notes from profiles efficiently, a common signer and many other Nostr helpers.

And of course they also have access to each other, by invoking actions on other apps and potentially getting responses back.

https://nostr.download/3e4f820b33bb915b547c7446772cb3b5c4…

If you are brave and wants to help, please try to download a binary from https://github.com/fiatjaf/verdana/actions/runs/36899284292 (or go to the most recent) or build it from source.

Here's a bunch of microapps if you want some inspiration: nostr:naddr1qvzqqqrhnypzqwlsccluhy6xxsr6l9a9uhhxf75g85g8a709tprjcn4e42h053vaqy2hwumn8ghj76twv3jhstnwva5hgtnyv4mz7qg4waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxuemfwshxgetk9uqq2mnpwpc8xnhuz22.

There are many things to do still. There is an Android app too that works similarly, but it's currently broken. And the "build your own client" needs more configurability aside from the manual picking of apps. But the desktop app has some cool things already, like the ability to create bundles of apps that you start from a shortcut.
https://nostr.download/3e4f820b33bb915b547c7446772cb3b5c4…

In the near future it would be nice to have someone share a big bundle of configuration and apps with others, so people are onboarded to Nostr with an experience and a set of microapps already pre-curated by a friend or some community leader; and later they learn how to customize things their own way. So this would be like a more flexible version of https://hallway.fiatjaf.com/.
I have no idea. Where are you getting these notifications? Are they Nostr events?
If you have good and strong headphones you can listen to all my criticisms of Lightning condensed in 1 hour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PD9UsU_jY4
This one was pretty good.
Many NIP-29 groups in the same stream of messages:
https://nostr.download/eb0fce4e3d7c490df42e694c28f028d32e…
What an amazing coincidence!
He used to say he didn't have a single Nostr profile because Nostr's identity system was broken and that he would just create a new key every time he wanted to interact with Nostr, so that means he deleted all these past profiles?
How come I still only see 3 upvotes? It had 2 when I first saw it, 3 with mine. 4 hours later many more comments and likes on this note and still 3 upvotes there.
After 16 years I've decided that petnames are actually good.
https://blossom.primal.net/34834d31b9382aff6fee606d8bcf47…
Looks good, sadly very few people understand.

I hope you keep it online while we navigate through the great Nostr reshapening, when old beliefs about Nostr being a global view of the world (indexed by npub1nlk894teh248w… for free on behalf of everyone) die and a new Nostr understanding arises, driven by custom relays and outbox following.
That would be a big loss for Nostr.
I've seen some examples of some illiterate Brazilians that said they never use the internet, they only use WhatsApp and Facebook.

I think this proves npub18ams6ewn5aj2n…'s point once and for all.
I hadn't understood Bluesky enough when I wrote this: nostr:naddr1qqyxzc33xyerwenzqyghwumn8ghj7enfv96x5ctx9e3k7mgzyqalp33lewf5vdq847t6te0wvnags0gs0mu72kz8938tn24wlfze6qcyqqq823cnrqw8w

My error (in the third point) was thinking that their goal was to make something actually decentralized like Nostr. For some reason I couldn't conceive the possibility that they were not trying to achieve this.

But they were. They were never interested in actual decentralization, probably because the idea that it was possible had never occurred to them.

They're stuck in thinking that you either have a flat p2p architecture (which leads to problems of incentives, spam, becoming a "nazi bar" and whatnot) or you have a system in which a platform controls everything and the best you can do is migrate.

nevent1qvzqqqqqqyp…
There are these basic ideas that I see repeated all the time, like "owning your data", that for some reason most people who comment on these protocols and technology topics have.

These people almost always come up with an understanding of Nostr that involves a "platform" or "app" and then users "own their data" and can "migrate" so they're not "locked".

I have no idea why so many people, including many people who actually support Nostr, have this weird understanding, it's like hardwired in their brains maybe, because these are exactly the same ideas that led to the creation of ATProto and Mastodon and many other dead protocols in the past.

In ATProto and in Mastodon the user really has an "account" in a "platform" and relies on that platform for everything. In Mastodon, though, the user is just stuck there forever. The great innovation of ATProto was making it so the user could do that and still "own their data" and "migrate" to another platform (of course they didn't really fix decentralized identities, just moved the problem to another platform that they control and controls everybody's identities, but that is besides the point).

Considering that people just see Nostr, read that it is a "decentralized protocol" and immediately assume it is some variant of the scheme above, the comparison with ATProto and Mastodon is of course necessary. But of course Nostr is not in that paradigm at all, it's a completely different thing. What would take them to understand?
I was going to ask what article you were commenting on, but apparently Google can still find exact phrases. It's this: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3r05g378w4o
1a) You can't, but it's harmless.
2b) No, it should appear always, it does for me as far as I've noticed.
3) That may be a bug, but I thought I had fixed it last month.
4) Thanks, I'll update that.
older →