X.KOJIRA.IO
Timeline

Penlock

[email protected]
npub1xlhmmmtmmk0v3l5heafjf4ktjqavhqwnkw455cnljettdamrzr3smlzcqv
Penlock is a tool to manually create a robust 2-of-3 backup of any seed phrase. It strengthens your self-custody setup, securing offsite recovery and inheritance without dependence on any third party.
Not at all, I was only asking. And yes you can absolutely do this with dice and coins, in fact I have done so before; but I have discovered this trick on my own and I'm not aware of other methods doing so.

About the dice comparison, I think tiles are more accessible and less prone to biases, which is why I picked this method at the end (it used to be coins). It is true that you need to print & cut the tiles, but you're going to need a printer for the wordlist anyway, so I like that it is not introducing any additional requirements.

At the end, people will use what they have according to their preference, and since the biases I mentioned are not large enough to create exploitable security risks, it's more a matter of polishing & optimization.
You pick a single block of 16 at random and iterate over the words in it, yes; that's how I solve it without relying on external tools, but maybe you don't call this solving then?
It *does* solve the checksum generation issue, from 5:00
As a clarification, my bias figures are rough estimates of the worst-case scenario for coins, dice, and tiles under good shuffles/throws. Someone correctly pointed out that not every coin or die will be as bad; but it's also easy to underestimate biases because it's generally twice what you'd intuitively expect. (e.g., a 52/48 coin has a 4% bias and generates only ~96 bits of entropy over 100 throws.)

The reason tiles (and cards alike) have a better safety profile is simple: low-quality coins/dice can be severely imbalanced, while the quality of a deck of tiles/cards has much less impact on the randomness of the draw. Moreover, the elements of a given deck are much easier to audit than the balance of a given coin or die.

Now, to be clear, even a 20% bias would still result in an unbreakable 12-word seed phrase. You'd still have 102.4 bits of entropy, plus 11 additional bits of security from BIP39 key stretching. But my goal with Penlock was to identify and deliver the method that best combines UX and security, and I believe paper tiles are it.
Actually, the process itself takes less than 10 minutes, but since you need to learn, print and cut first it's going to be closer than 30.

I don't think other processes let you avoid printing a wordlist, or then you're using a digital wordlist which might not be the most secure thing in the world especially if you have to scroll that thing back and forth to find your words.
Hello Jimmy, we just released a video tutorial to generate a seed phrase by hand with Penlock, thought you might be interested. While this requires minimal printing, we also got a manufactured version now, available in multiple Bitcoin spaces and soon on Geyser.

nevent1qvzqqqqqqyp…
nprofile1qyvhwumn8… Here's the video guide ;)