What's happening on Nostr?

Parman - Activate OP_GFY now!!
Bitcoin KYC cleaner (it's true), Bitcoin security and self-custody mentor, Bitcoin author, and private key whisperer.
PGP: E7C061D4C5E5BC98
Creator of Parmanode https://parmanode.com
Creator of ParmaDrive https://parmanode.com/parmadrive
Creator of ParmanodL https://parmanode.com/parmanodl
Creator of ParmAirGap https://parmanode.com/parmairgap
Creator of BitVotr Protocol https://bitvotr.com
Bitcoin Mentorship https://armantheparman.com/mentorship
KYC Free Collaborative Custody Service https://armantheparman.com/parmanvault
Lost Bitcoin/Crypto Recovery Service https://armantheparman.com/recovery/
Security Review Service https://armantheparman.com/bsr
Assiter of Boomers https://bitcoin4boomers.com
Essays
PGP: E7C061D4C5E5BC98
Creator of Parmanode https://parmanode.com
Creator of ParmaDrive https://parmanode.com/parmadrive
Creator of ParmanodL https://parmanode.com/parmanodl
Creator of ParmAirGap https://parmanode.com/parmairgap
Creator of BitVotr Protocol https://bitvotr.com
Bitcoin Mentorship https://armantheparman.com/mentorship
KYC Free Collaborative Custody Service https://armantheparman.com/parmanvault
Lost Bitcoin/Crypto Recovery Service https://armantheparman.com/recovery/
Security Review Service https://armantheparman.com/bsr
Assiter of Boomers https://bitcoin4boomers.com
Essays
When you send fiat to an exchange, use it ALL to buy bitcoin, then completely empty the account by withdrawing the bitcoin.
Don't trade, don't fuck around.
Then you'll have a UTXO in your wallet and its cost base is exactly the fiat deposit amount. Every fee in-between is irrelevant if you do it this way.
One deposit, one UTXO - cost base is easy. Keep your withdrawal to over 500k sats if you can, otherwise do multiple small fiat deposits and they all are added to get your cost base (if you do a full withdrawal).
Then if you decide to sell/spend any, you'll be in a good position to select the most cost effective UTXO to use, to minimise the tax that is being extorted from you.
It's best to use the per-parcel accounting method rather than first-in-first-out (FIFO), and stick with that one method.
If you don't keep track of your UTXOs properly, you'll have to default to FIFO method of accounting which is not great.
None of this is financial advice, because Bitcoin is a virtual currency, it's not real! 🤪
Don't trade, don't fuck around.
Then you'll have a UTXO in your wallet and its cost base is exactly the fiat deposit amount. Every fee in-between is irrelevant if you do it this way.
One deposit, one UTXO - cost base is easy. Keep your withdrawal to over 500k sats if you can, otherwise do multiple small fiat deposits and they all are added to get your cost base (if you do a full withdrawal).
Then if you decide to sell/spend any, you'll be in a good position to select the most cost effective UTXO to use, to minimise the tax that is being extorted from you.
It's best to use the per-parcel accounting method rather than first-in-first-out (FIFO), and stick with that one method.
If you don't keep track of your UTXOs properly, you'll have to default to FIFO method of accounting which is not great.
None of this is financial advice, because Bitcoin is a virtual currency, it's not real! 🤪
New Parman Guide, it's been a while, sorry.
"Large QR codes and how to capture them"
armantheparman.com/largeqr/
https://blossom.primal.net/506c268e21714ae07c1d20065a1646…
"Large QR codes and how to capture them"
armantheparman.com/largeqr/
https://blossom.primal.net/506c268e21714ae07c1d20065a1646…
Ladies, if your husband introduced you as "my current wife", what happens after that?
A node enforces the rules about a person's choice of money.
For example, if you buy something from me, and my node says I haven't been paid, even if you had one million nodes saying I've been paid, my single node overrides anything your nodes say.
I have nodes here for you, ready and synced (accepting bitcoin only for payment)...
https://parman.org
For example, if you buy something from me, and my node says I haven't been paid, even if you had one million nodes saying I've been paid, my single node overrides anything your nodes say.
I have nodes here for you, ready and synced (accepting bitcoin only for payment)...
https://parman.org
If you and a friend each bought a ParmaDrive, then you could back up data to each other's machine and never have to pay for cloud data storage again.
You can access your data from other computers or your phone, even if you leave home.
If you like Windows, eww, you can still use Windows, and access the ParmaDrive server.
If you need help learning to use it, there is an option for that at checkout.
https://parman.org/parmadrive
https://blossom.primal.net/5d71769b3bf00fcc6329750937fc20…
You can access your data from other computers or your phone, even if you leave home.
If you like Windows, eww, you can still use Windows, and access the ParmaDrive server.
If you need help learning to use it, there is an option for that at checkout.
https://parman.org/parmadrive
https://blossom.primal.net/5d71769b3bf00fcc6329750937fc20…
There are no more cycles. You buy bitcoin because it's becoming money and you're disgusted using money others can create for free.
You can order a ready-made, fully Bitcoin-synced Laptop node (ParmanodL) which has the Parmanode software installed, configured, and tested, delivered to anywhere in the world (except Eptstein's Island, sorry Andy).
People don't understand you can buy mined #ƨats with your KYC sats.
https://privatehash.net
https://blossom.primal.net/67d48ed572c6c23bb557d1f913b910…
https://privatehash.net
https://blossom.primal.net/67d48ed572c6c23bb557d1f913b910…
I'm sorry to have to bring you this news, but you need significantly more bitcoin than you currently have today.
Once upon a time, someone exploited a bug and got 184 billion bitcoins.
The VALID TRANSACTIONS were rugged by Satoshi to keep bitcoin going.
Today, another exploit (that Core refuses to acknowledge or fix) is damaging Bitcoin.
Similarly to the previous bug fix, where a malicious exploiter was rugged, should "valid transaction" be a reason to not fix Bitcoin?
It requires consensus that fixing a life threatening bug overrides immutability.
It's uncomfortable to talk about, but if you think about it, OF COURSE the survival of Bitcoin logically supercedes immutability.
And so, the debate should be about if this is really going to destroy Bitcoin if left unchecked. That conversation is being drowned out by appealing to less important principles of money.
I think we should first determine that, then encourage discussions about how to fix it, always remembering that the highest principle is Bitcoin surviving as digital sound money for the world.
It's OK to entertain an idea, like rugging malicious spammers, perhaps deciding against it, or not, or finding an alternative.
It was easier to fix when Satoshi was in charge and Bitcoin wasn't decentralised, now we all have to decide, all while the enemy is sending bots, and Adam Back, to muddy the waters and distract us from the most important conversations.
The VALID TRANSACTIONS were rugged by Satoshi to keep bitcoin going.
Today, another exploit (that Core refuses to acknowledge or fix) is damaging Bitcoin.
Similarly to the previous bug fix, where a malicious exploiter was rugged, should "valid transaction" be a reason to not fix Bitcoin?
It requires consensus that fixing a life threatening bug overrides immutability.
It's uncomfortable to talk about, but if you think about it, OF COURSE the survival of Bitcoin logically supercedes immutability.
And so, the debate should be about if this is really going to destroy Bitcoin if left unchecked. That conversation is being drowned out by appealing to less important principles of money.
I think we should first determine that, then encourage discussions about how to fix it, always remembering that the highest principle is Bitcoin surviving as digital sound money for the world.
It's OK to entertain an idea, like rugging malicious spammers, perhaps deciding against it, or not, or finding an alternative.
It was easier to fix when Satoshi was in charge and Bitcoin wasn't decentralised, now we all have to decide, all while the enemy is sending bots, and Adam Back, to muddy the waters and distract us from the most important conversations.
The problem with arbitrary data tolerance is that it doesn't contribute to Bitcoin being money.
It's like promoting the electrical conductivity of gold as a reason for it to be money.
You might think that's not so bad but...
The problem it causes, having arbitrary data, is subjectivity, and various attacks - it's easier to stand for none of it, and remain objectively supporting Bitcoin as money.
You don't need to define what spam is - it's a subset of arbitrary data.
You don't need to defend Bitcoin being a free speech platform (it's not), and explain why CSAM can't be blocked - it's a subset of arbitrary data.
You don't need to care that not all arbitrary data can't be stopped - your principles are what guides you, and with the right principles, if people concur, consensus is easy to achieve.
Right now, we're fractured, because people who don't want spam feel like they have to allow it because it's hard to define (and because shitcoiners and fiat maxis are disguising themselves as one of us, muddying the waters, looking at Lopp and others).
I'm saying this is unnecessary. Just be against arbitrary data; it's not part of Bitcoin's purpose.
If you desire extra "nice to have" features from arbitrary data, in addition to Bitcoin's pure monetary features, then you have to accept spam and CSAM, and unwanted additional attacks, and also damaging infighting.
It's like promoting the electrical conductivity of gold as a reason for it to be money.
You might think that's not so bad but...
The problem it causes, having arbitrary data, is subjectivity, and various attacks - it's easier to stand for none of it, and remain objectively supporting Bitcoin as money.
You don't need to define what spam is - it's a subset of arbitrary data.
You don't need to defend Bitcoin being a free speech platform (it's not), and explain why CSAM can't be blocked - it's a subset of arbitrary data.
You don't need to care that not all arbitrary data can't be stopped - your principles are what guides you, and with the right principles, if people concur, consensus is easy to achieve.
Right now, we're fractured, because people who don't want spam feel like they have to allow it because it's hard to define (and because shitcoiners and fiat maxis are disguising themselves as one of us, muddying the waters, looking at Lopp and others).
I'm saying this is unnecessary. Just be against arbitrary data; it's not part of Bitcoin's purpose.
If you desire extra "nice to have" features from arbitrary data, in addition to Bitcoin's pure monetary features, then you have to accept spam and CSAM, and unwanted additional attacks, and also damaging infighting.
Life cycle of a DCA transaction...
When your filthy bank releases your government tyranny tokens to your exchange after a malicious 24 hour hold (for your safety), the price of bitcoin pamps 10% moments before the tyrannical coins are shown in your Coinbase account.
You then no-look insta smash yolo market buy bitcoin.
But there's a problem...
Your Coinbase account page shows a bitcoin balance, but you're not looking at bitcoin, you're looking at Coinbase's database entry of what they owe you. So the job isn't finished.
You will withdraw, and then after you prove you have access to your email, and you're not using Tor, and you complete a captcha, and log in to authenticator and enter numbers, and then a phone text confirmation, THHHEEENN, Coinbase employees will go to their ParmanodL laptop and locate a UTXO from their watching wallet, and then make a transaction to your bitcoin address, and then export the tx to their ParmAirGap machine for signing, which then returns the signed transaction back to the ParmanodL transaction/node latop, and broadcasts the signed transactions to it's own bitcoin Knots server (on the same machine).
The node then shares the unconfirmed transaction to other nodes, and they "gossip" share it to all the other nodes in the world.
Eventually, your Datum instance on your ParmanodL machine will fashion from its filtered mempool a potential block and include your incoming transaction. One of your BitAxes will then mine the block and win.
It will then gossip the winning block before other miners claim victory, and all the nodes in the world will update their "tip" block. All miners will then attempt to win the next block.
You mining address will be paid a bit over 3.125 bitcoin which is allowed to be spent after 100 blocks, congratulations 🎉, but also in that winning block is the transaction that Coinbase paid your address.
Your ParmanodL laptop that has Sparrow open, and syncing with your fulcrum/electrs server, which syncs to your bitcoin Knots blockchain (all on the same machine), will notice the new payment in the fulcrum/electrs database and Sparrow will show the new bitcoin in your wallet.
Feeling deep and unshakable satisfaction, you then close all the apps, and leave the laptop open, connected to power, monitor dimmed, so that Knots running in the background will stay up to date, and go outside to touch grass, as they say.
You know you can totally shut it down, but you prefer leaving it on as is ready instantly when you need it, and you will for your mentoring video meeting with Parman next morning.
Tomorrow, you will do it all again.
When your filthy bank releases your government tyranny tokens to your exchange after a malicious 24 hour hold (for your safety), the price of bitcoin pamps 10% moments before the tyrannical coins are shown in your Coinbase account.
You then no-look insta smash yolo market buy bitcoin.
But there's a problem...
Your Coinbase account page shows a bitcoin balance, but you're not looking at bitcoin, you're looking at Coinbase's database entry of what they owe you. So the job isn't finished.
You will withdraw, and then after you prove you have access to your email, and you're not using Tor, and you complete a captcha, and log in to authenticator and enter numbers, and then a phone text confirmation, THHHEEENN, Coinbase employees will go to their ParmanodL laptop and locate a UTXO from their watching wallet, and then make a transaction to your bitcoin address, and then export the tx to their ParmAirGap machine for signing, which then returns the signed transaction back to the ParmanodL transaction/node latop, and broadcasts the signed transactions to it's own bitcoin Knots server (on the same machine).
The node then shares the unconfirmed transaction to other nodes, and they "gossip" share it to all the other nodes in the world.
Eventually, your Datum instance on your ParmanodL machine will fashion from its filtered mempool a potential block and include your incoming transaction. One of your BitAxes will then mine the block and win.
It will then gossip the winning block before other miners claim victory, and all the nodes in the world will update their "tip" block. All miners will then attempt to win the next block.
You mining address will be paid a bit over 3.125 bitcoin which is allowed to be spent after 100 blocks, congratulations 🎉, but also in that winning block is the transaction that Coinbase paid your address.
Your ParmanodL laptop that has Sparrow open, and syncing with your fulcrum/electrs server, which syncs to your bitcoin Knots blockchain (all on the same machine), will notice the new payment in the fulcrum/electrs database and Sparrow will show the new bitcoin in your wallet.
Feeling deep and unshakable satisfaction, you then close all the apps, and leave the laptop open, connected to power, monitor dimmed, so that Knots running in the background will stay up to date, and go outside to touch grass, as they say.
You know you can totally shut it down, but you prefer leaving it on as is ready instantly when you need it, and you will for your mentoring video meeting with Parman next morning.
Tomorrow, you will do it all again.
Humanity is going to do just fine without an immutable database of arbitrary data, but is completely fuçk3d if we don't have Bitcoin as MONEY.
We only get one chance.
Run Knots, hurry up.
We only get one chance.
Run Knots, hurry up.
Bitcoin Core will be used as a mule for free, unstoppable CP/CSAM by sickos or state actors, in order to attack Bitcoin and prosecute those who knowingly allow it.
This is the attack...
Once op_return is removed, plain JPEG images (not part of multiple fragments inside scripts that need to be pieced together and decoded, but plain JPEG/GIF/MP4) will be sent through your Bitcoin HardCore node version 30+, from one paedophile to others, possibly sold (Knots runners won't touch them, ever). Your Core node will happily pass it along, providing anonymity to the criminals (or state attackers, or Epstein's old clients).
They will pay a well below market rate initially (eventually zero), and never even need to get the transaction mined - key point. The original filter that Satoshi introduced, FEES, will be effectively bypassed...
After some time, these low-fee CP/CSAM txs will be dropped by Bitcoin Core nodes, but if they don't, the sicko(s) can do an RBF of the transaction (or if they have chained them, an RBF of a single low-fee unconfirmed parent), to cancel and invalidate the transaction so they don't have to actually pay for any of the downstream higher fee large transactions.
They will have successfully used your computer to transfer and potentially sell horrible images, without paying (so forget "filters don't work, they'll get on chain anyway"), thanks you being complicit, and thanks to all the Core devs who allowed this in. And those gaslighting against us saying this is wrong.
Then public opinion will turn heavily against Bitcoiners, if it isn't bad enough now. We already know it's going to get worse as most miss out.
@adam3us has pointed out, incorrectly (I'll explain), that this attack can't work, because of some "package relay". Sounds like this is a filter to stop RBFs of a parent if there is a long chain of transactions dependent on it.
A clever idea, but it can't work, Adam. Do you know why? Because your resistance itself is a form of FILTER, and FILTERS DON'T WORK, remember? You can not use an argument against us if that same argument is used to defend yourself.
An attacker can get their cancelling RBF transaction mined by going directly to a miner. Then the scumbags get away with using your Bictoin Core node for CP/CSAM transmission - it's irrelevant whether it gets on a block or not, it doesn't need to, the paying paedophile got his images.
Ironically, filters not working is the very reason we need filters.
There are 3 solutions.
1) Bitcoin Core reverses this STUPID rushed decision, introducing completely unnecessary risk to Bitcoin.
2) We all run Knots, and it becomes the reference client.
3) We move away from Core to Knots, and maybe others will pop up, and there is no reference client, meaning fewer meaningful changes to Bitcoin become likely.
Bitcoin doesn't need changes; it needs general light maintenance, so just maintain it, don't change it!
x.com/adam3us/status…
This is the attack...
Once op_return is removed, plain JPEG images (not part of multiple fragments inside scripts that need to be pieced together and decoded, but plain JPEG/GIF/MP4) will be sent through your Bitcoin HardCore node version 30+, from one paedophile to others, possibly sold (Knots runners won't touch them, ever). Your Core node will happily pass it along, providing anonymity to the criminals (or state attackers, or Epstein's old clients).
They will pay a well below market rate initially (eventually zero), and never even need to get the transaction mined - key point. The original filter that Satoshi introduced, FEES, will be effectively bypassed...
After some time, these low-fee CP/CSAM txs will be dropped by Bitcoin Core nodes, but if they don't, the sicko(s) can do an RBF of the transaction (or if they have chained them, an RBF of a single low-fee unconfirmed parent), to cancel and invalidate the transaction so they don't have to actually pay for any of the downstream higher fee large transactions.
They will have successfully used your computer to transfer and potentially sell horrible images, without paying (so forget "filters don't work, they'll get on chain anyway"), thanks you being complicit, and thanks to all the Core devs who allowed this in. And those gaslighting against us saying this is wrong.
Then public opinion will turn heavily against Bitcoiners, if it isn't bad enough now. We already know it's going to get worse as most miss out.
@adam3us has pointed out, incorrectly (I'll explain), that this attack can't work, because of some "package relay". Sounds like this is a filter to stop RBFs of a parent if there is a long chain of transactions dependent on it.
A clever idea, but it can't work, Adam. Do you know why? Because your resistance itself is a form of FILTER, and FILTERS DON'T WORK, remember? You can not use an argument against us if that same argument is used to defend yourself.
An attacker can get their cancelling RBF transaction mined by going directly to a miner. Then the scumbags get away with using your Bictoin Core node for CP/CSAM transmission - it's irrelevant whether it gets on a block or not, it doesn't need to, the paying paedophile got his images.
Ironically, filters not working is the very reason we need filters.
There are 3 solutions.
1) Bitcoin Core reverses this STUPID rushed decision, introducing completely unnecessary risk to Bitcoin.
2) We all run Knots, and it becomes the reference client.
3) We move away from Core to Knots, and maybe others will pop up, and there is no reference client, meaning fewer meaningful changes to Bitcoin become likely.
Bitcoin doesn't need changes; it needs general light maintenance, so just maintain it, don't change it!
x.com/adam3us/status…
Today on "Old man yells at society" ...
Self serve checkout at Safeway, staffed by 5 people ushering people to checkout... "Paying by card?"
STFU, everyone is paying by card, you're just in the way.
Just make each machine accept card or cash and you save paying the salary of five people.
They tukerrjowbs!!
Self serve checkout at Safeway, staffed by 5 people ushering people to checkout... "Paying by card?"
STFU, everyone is paying by card, you're just in the way.
Just make each machine accept card or cash and you save paying the salary of five people.
They tukerrjowbs!!
ParmaKnots dot com has a privacy policy which is implicitly accepted by you if you buy anything at all, or even just browse the website...
"PRIVACY POLICY: Your data will not be shared with anyone under any circumstances - those asking for information or wanting to buy data can fuck off."
https://parmaknots.com
"PRIVACY POLICY: Your data will not be shared with anyone under any circumstances - those asking for information or wanting to buy data can fuck off."
https://parmaknots.com
Switzerland is a waste of energy. It could be used to mine bitcoin instead.
Did you know that BTCPay server with Parmanode is freakin great and will continue to improve?
Installing is easy AF.
Connecting lightning liquidity to BTCPay is made easy AF.
Back up and restoring database is made easy AF with Parmanode custom backup script.
Lightning channel backups are easy AF.
Lightning Watchtower easy AF.
Might do automated backups next, and then ParmaSync to a ParmaTwin (yours or a friend's remote encrypted server) nightly.
Be entertained.
Installing is easy AF.
Connecting lightning liquidity to BTCPay is made easy AF.
Back up and restoring database is made easy AF with Parmanode custom backup script.
Lightning channel backups are easy AF.
Lightning Watchtower easy AF.
Might do automated backups next, and then ParmaSync to a ParmaTwin (yours or a friend's remote encrypted server) nightly.
Be entertained.
Sometimes you find out, without ever having had fucked around...
Lost a computer to hardware failure the other day. Recovery practices are good, got another up an running the next day, and then that died too. Fuck.
Suspecting voltage issues through a 30m ethernet cable - I didn't know that could be an issue.
Painful lesson.
Server is down, btcpay is down, please don't try to by anything while I'm asleep 😬, I'll fix it tomorrow, bed time.
"Parman's Free Bitcoin Guides" is hosted, so that is going strong, your toilet reading shouldn't be interrupted.
Lost a computer to hardware failure the other day. Recovery practices are good, got another up an running the next day, and then that died too. Fuck.
Suspecting voltage issues through a 30m ethernet cable - I didn't know that could be an issue.
Painful lesson.
Server is down, btcpay is down, please don't try to by anything while I'm asleep 😬, I'll fix it tomorrow, bed time.
"Parman's Free Bitcoin Guides" is hosted, so that is going strong, your toilet reading shouldn't be interrupted.
Probably AI. Australians are compliant.
THE PROBLEM
To flourish, humanity needs to go back to free market money (not issued by central banks or governments, but arising from the market) that can’t be manipulated by central banks and/or governments, nor eradicated. This money also needs to be digital, to facilitate international value transfer, yet scarce (digital tokens have always been “copyable”).
Gold used to work well, but being physical, as trade expanded beyond the local town to international trade, peer-to-peer exchange of gold became impractical. The solution to that weakness was to centralize it (using bank ledgers instead, or bank “notes”), and digitize it (digitization of notes/contracts), allowing banks to become intermediaries of all non-P2P transfers of money. Gold’s physical nature led to the introduction of gold-backed paper/digital money, but then ultimately to fiat money — government-issued money not backed by anything at all, not even gold. Fiat money costs nothing to produce, is not scarce, and allows governments to avoid market forces. It allows the government to always expand, facilitating a relentless and gradual march to worldwide totalitarianism.
Satoshi Nakamoto solved this problem with Bitcoin.
THE SOLUTION
Using a distributed ledger (ledger, meaning a record of all the transactions; distributed, meaning existing in many places at once, all in synchrony), and disappearing from the public, he spawned a money that has no central authority, no CEO — no one at all, who can be asked/forced to shut it down. Every single node needs to be eradicated to eliminate Bitcoin, and there are thousands scattered all over the planet.
That lack of central authority in a digital token would leave a problem — double-spending. How can anyone be sure of the true state of the ledger? What if a token existing in wallet number one that has been spent, is spent again from wallet number one? Who decides which payment was first, and which was later (and is illegitimate)?
This was solved partly by creating the timechain (“blockchain”). Transactions are put in blocks — data grouped together, like pages in a book — and each block includes the hash of the previous block.
With the blockchain, the order of these blocks can’t simply be changed around without anyone noticing. If somebody changes transactions in block number one, then the hash of block one will change. The hash of block one is part of the data of block two. That means changing block one will cause the data (the hash) in block two to be wrong. That makes block two invalid. If block two is invalid, then every block after that would be invalid. You can’t have block 750,000 be valid if block two was not valid:
The blockchain makes the ledger tamper-evident.
The second part of the solution to double-spending was proof-of-work. Note that a re-ordering (or rewriting) of blocks is actually quite easy (and almost costless) to do — it just requires a computer to redo the hashes and link the blocks together. If a new version was presented to you, there isn’t a way for you to know which version is correct — without proof-of-work. What Satoshi Nakamoto did was use PoW (invented previously by Dr. Adam Back) to make these hashes costly to produce.
This costliness was introduced by adding a rule to the Bitcoin protocol, placing restrictions on what hash results are valid, necessitating multiple brute-force attempts at hashing in order to meet the requirement. Random brute force attempts by a computer, that cost electricity, is how it’s done, but it is often explained in a way that’s wrong and hated by informed Bitcoiners. “Bitcoin miners are looking for solutions to difficult math problems.” They are not math problems.
If attackers were to modify block one, they’d have to also find a valid hash (by entering and iterating some meaningless data until the hash is valid), then enter the new hash into block two and in doing so invalidate the hash of block two. They’d have to change block two in such a way to make it hash correctly, and then put that hash in block three, modifying block three.
Then they’d have to repeat the work done to hash block three, and so on, all the way to the current block. The energy expended in mining Bitcoin blocks thus protects the network from attack by making it too expensive to repeat all the energy use. To rewrite Bitcoin from block one would require a repetition of the entire world’s cumulative energy expended on Bitcoin so far.
Proof-of-work makes the blockchain tamper-proof.
The other purpose of PoW is to solve the “Byzantine Generals’ Problem.” This arises in a distributed network of computers all needing to know the current state of affairs, and no message between computers can be trusted to report the current state (just like the predicament of the Byzantine Generals).
The Byzantine Generals’ problem is solved by creating a rule that the chain of Bitcoin blocks with the most cumulative work is the valid chain (often approximated as “the longest chain”). This eliminates any requirement to trust an authority to state which version of the timechain is the valid one, should there be any discrepancy, and simply relies on everyone agreeing to that rule of “most work = the valid chain.”
Another problem that Nakamoto considered when creating new money is the problem of fair issuance, and how to do it in such a way to maximize adoption. Nakamoto achieved this by staggering the release of new coins, allowing some of the later adopters access to newly issued coins.
50 bitcoins are released to miners every block, which occurs on average every 10 minutes, and that number of coins issued is halved every 210,000 blocks which is roughly every 4 years. Due to the programmed halving of issuance, there will come a day (estimated in the year 2140) where no further division is possible past the smallest unit (1 Satoshi = 0.00000001 bitcoin), and therefore the supply is mathematically capped and very close to 21 million coins.
The difficulty adjustment was also crucial to prevent the supply cap of 21 million coins from being brought in ahead of schedule — it’s interesting to note, for the experienced Bitcoiner, that the difficulty adjustment does not affect the supply cap of bitcoin as such — it just prevents a change to the schedule of release. Even if there was no difficulty adjustment, the 21 million cap can not be breached.
Finally, the creation of this money affected something outside the code – game theory. In the same way that the human genome is ultimately responsible for magnificent monuments and works of art, those things are not actually found in our genetic code. This is described by “The Extended Phenotype,” a book and term coined by Richard Dawkins. Bitcoin’s code results in humans acting in such a way to ensure its success. When you learn about Bitcoin in-depth, and the game theory surrounding it, you naturally come to this conclusion:
The only thing that can stop Bitcoin is worldwide coordinated authoritarianism, and the only thing that can stop worldwide coordinated authoritarianism is Bitcoin.
https://armantheparman.com/tpwm/
To flourish, humanity needs to go back to free market money (not issued by central banks or governments, but arising from the market) that can’t be manipulated by central banks and/or governments, nor eradicated. This money also needs to be digital, to facilitate international value transfer, yet scarce (digital tokens have always been “copyable”).
Gold used to work well, but being physical, as trade expanded beyond the local town to international trade, peer-to-peer exchange of gold became impractical. The solution to that weakness was to centralize it (using bank ledgers instead, or bank “notes”), and digitize it (digitization of notes/contracts), allowing banks to become intermediaries of all non-P2P transfers of money. Gold’s physical nature led to the introduction of gold-backed paper/digital money, but then ultimately to fiat money — government-issued money not backed by anything at all, not even gold. Fiat money costs nothing to produce, is not scarce, and allows governments to avoid market forces. It allows the government to always expand, facilitating a relentless and gradual march to worldwide totalitarianism.
Satoshi Nakamoto solved this problem with Bitcoin.
THE SOLUTION
Using a distributed ledger (ledger, meaning a record of all the transactions; distributed, meaning existing in many places at once, all in synchrony), and disappearing from the public, he spawned a money that has no central authority, no CEO — no one at all, who can be asked/forced to shut it down. Every single node needs to be eradicated to eliminate Bitcoin, and there are thousands scattered all over the planet.
That lack of central authority in a digital token would leave a problem — double-spending. How can anyone be sure of the true state of the ledger? What if a token existing in wallet number one that has been spent, is spent again from wallet number one? Who decides which payment was first, and which was later (and is illegitimate)?
This was solved partly by creating the timechain (“blockchain”). Transactions are put in blocks — data grouped together, like pages in a book — and each block includes the hash of the previous block.
With the blockchain, the order of these blocks can’t simply be changed around without anyone noticing. If somebody changes transactions in block number one, then the hash of block one will change. The hash of block one is part of the data of block two. That means changing block one will cause the data (the hash) in block two to be wrong. That makes block two invalid. If block two is invalid, then every block after that would be invalid. You can’t have block 750,000 be valid if block two was not valid:
The blockchain makes the ledger tamper-evident.
The second part of the solution to double-spending was proof-of-work. Note that a re-ordering (or rewriting) of blocks is actually quite easy (and almost costless) to do — it just requires a computer to redo the hashes and link the blocks together. If a new version was presented to you, there isn’t a way for you to know which version is correct — without proof-of-work. What Satoshi Nakamoto did was use PoW (invented previously by Dr. Adam Back) to make these hashes costly to produce.
This costliness was introduced by adding a rule to the Bitcoin protocol, placing restrictions on what hash results are valid, necessitating multiple brute-force attempts at hashing in order to meet the requirement. Random brute force attempts by a computer, that cost electricity, is how it’s done, but it is often explained in a way that’s wrong and hated by informed Bitcoiners. “Bitcoin miners are looking for solutions to difficult math problems.” They are not math problems.
If attackers were to modify block one, they’d have to also find a valid hash (by entering and iterating some meaningless data until the hash is valid), then enter the new hash into block two and in doing so invalidate the hash of block two. They’d have to change block two in such a way to make it hash correctly, and then put that hash in block three, modifying block three.
Then they’d have to repeat the work done to hash block three, and so on, all the way to the current block. The energy expended in mining Bitcoin blocks thus protects the network from attack by making it too expensive to repeat all the energy use. To rewrite Bitcoin from block one would require a repetition of the entire world’s cumulative energy expended on Bitcoin so far.
Proof-of-work makes the blockchain tamper-proof.
The other purpose of PoW is to solve the “Byzantine Generals’ Problem.” This arises in a distributed network of computers all needing to know the current state of affairs, and no message between computers can be trusted to report the current state (just like the predicament of the Byzantine Generals).
The Byzantine Generals’ problem is solved by creating a rule that the chain of Bitcoin blocks with the most cumulative work is the valid chain (often approximated as “the longest chain”). This eliminates any requirement to trust an authority to state which version of the timechain is the valid one, should there be any discrepancy, and simply relies on everyone agreeing to that rule of “most work = the valid chain.”
Another problem that Nakamoto considered when creating new money is the problem of fair issuance, and how to do it in such a way to maximize adoption. Nakamoto achieved this by staggering the release of new coins, allowing some of the later adopters access to newly issued coins.
50 bitcoins are released to miners every block, which occurs on average every 10 minutes, and that number of coins issued is halved every 210,000 blocks which is roughly every 4 years. Due to the programmed halving of issuance, there will come a day (estimated in the year 2140) where no further division is possible past the smallest unit (1 Satoshi = 0.00000001 bitcoin), and therefore the supply is mathematically capped and very close to 21 million coins.
The difficulty adjustment was also crucial to prevent the supply cap of 21 million coins from being brought in ahead of schedule — it’s interesting to note, for the experienced Bitcoiner, that the difficulty adjustment does not affect the supply cap of bitcoin as such — it just prevents a change to the schedule of release. Even if there was no difficulty adjustment, the 21 million cap can not be breached.
Finally, the creation of this money affected something outside the code – game theory. In the same way that the human genome is ultimately responsible for magnificent monuments and works of art, those things are not actually found in our genetic code. This is described by “The Extended Phenotype,” a book and term coined by Richard Dawkins. Bitcoin’s code results in humans acting in such a way to ensure its success. When you learn about Bitcoin in-depth, and the game theory surrounding it, you naturally come to this conclusion:
The only thing that can stop Bitcoin is worldwide coordinated authoritarianism, and the only thing that can stop worldwide coordinated authoritarianism is Bitcoin.
https://armantheparman.com/tpwm/
Termites. Fuck. Gonna cost me sats.
That's a fucken lotta zaps
I just spent 4 hrs carefully migrating my home server which was set up years ago as Ubuntu (before I knew any better) to a Debian ParmaDrive, and loved every damn minute of it.
Bitcoin, LND and channels, btcpay server (making use of Parmanode database backup & restore feature) with domain and reverse proxy, electrs, fulcrum, RTL, Tor services/onions/configs, home directory files, SSH keys, and new drive encryption with VPS unlock (ParmaGaurd).
I feel like I'm forgetting something. Oh shit, I lost my private keys.
4 hours and is not bad actually.
Once upon a time this would have taken me about a few days maybe a week.
I didn't jump right in though, I did spend a few days thinking about it in the back of my mind, just to make sure I don't fuck it up.
Bitcoin, LND and channels, btcpay server (making use of Parmanode database backup & restore feature) with domain and reverse proxy, electrs, fulcrum, RTL, Tor services/onions/configs, home directory files, SSH keys, and new drive encryption with VPS unlock (ParmaGaurd).
I feel like I'm forgetting something. Oh shit, I lost my private keys.
4 hours and is not bad actually.
Once upon a time this would have taken me about a few days maybe a week.
I didn't jump right in though, I did spend a few days thinking about it in the back of my mind, just to make sure I don't fuck it up.
I just opened a fresh new packet of cassia bark, best before date: 2017.
That's a good word
I dream of a day when there's nobody wrong on the internet.
I'm enjoying being a maths teacher for my daughter in self-custody homeschooling.
Today I introduced polynomials and manipulating curves on 2D axes.
Tomorrow I think I'm going to whip out, "It's just math" 😂
Today I introduced polynomials and manipulating curves on 2D axes.
Tomorrow I think I'm going to whip out, "It's just math" 😂
OK, fucken great


