X.KOJIRA.IO
Timeline

WalletScrutiny

[email protected]
npub1j9kttlc86w63emmldd4h74rekyqpksqup6p9trhp5gjsf374qlyszvuswx
Know your wallet like you made it!

Our goal is to improve the security of Bitcoin wallets by examining products for transparency and potential attacks.
We’ve been busy but quiet these last months. npub1qw6sxmwrmwpxq… improved the site a lot by adding new features around #nostr based build verifications.

We hope other projects in the nostr ecosystem like npub1wf4pufsucer5v… npub10r8xl2njyepcw… will see the value of these verifications and start integrating them. The more products that build on reproducibility, the more users can truly apply the principle of “Don’t trust - verify.” Binary transparency shouldn’t remain a niche feature - it needs to become the default.

If you run software that touches your private keys - be it nostr clients or bitcoin wallets - without binary transparency, only whoever built the binary really knows what code you’re running.

https://files.nostr.info/f541e0eac3777d04aa0df5a70e623ca7…

npub1r709glp0xx2zv… and npub1vf6wyw9j38sm9… checked the reproducibility of almost 300 binaries. The 304 verifications by nprofile1qqspdzm69… are all the old verifications we had migrated to nostr. And the backlog keeps growing as we cover more and more products with frequent updates.

Are we doing something valuable for the space? A npub1spralxq6jlw5r… grant says yes, and community endorsements confirm it - but the project itself also needs scrutiny.

We recently introduced "verification endorsements":

https://files.nostr.info/1df1964ded1bec6109f672f5eaf0b5ca…

This is a simple contribution many could provide. If you read a verification and it looked plausible and complete and you trust the author, mark the verification as verified. If you ran the documented commands yourself on your hardware and got to similar results, please endorse the verification!

Even more importantly label verifications as invalid and leave a comment about what's missing when you find issues! Don't be shy!

Our goal is to document all steps such that all mildly technical users (you should be comfortable with a Linux shell) can reproduce our findings. If that's not the case, please provide your feedback and we will improve ✋.

And if you maintain one of the products we check, share your own verification as a template for others!
The re-design is finally live!

Great thanks to

* Spiral for sponsoring us
* the Bitcoin Design Community for awesome improvements that we have refined over 16(?) calls and who knows how much research between the calls
* npub1vwufmh57qdhrv… who implemented the very challenging changes over 350 commits!

Check it out at https://walletscrutiny.com/

Please be gentil. We probably have missed many details. Bug reports and feature requests are as always welcome at https://gitlab.com/walletscrutiny/walletScrutinyCom/-/issues
What should we do about a bad actor making it to the top of our list? We don't test for being honest. We only test for source code transparency.

https://habla.news/a/naddr1qqxnzd3cxsmrgvejxvunqde5qy08wu…
Those links used to be all with the universal 🌐 globe symbol. Now the most common brands are easier to spot ...

https://void.cat/d/8v2YLo2F5a8xvwgo4BZQMu.webp
So [Trust being closed source](https://walletscrutiny.com/android/com.wallet.crypto.trus… this is either/or:

⚠️ a fork of many years back when it was still open source
⚠️ an app built from the decompiled Trust app

And then there is

⚠️ [last reviews all bad and scam accusations](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.simpleh… to one of which they replied to "Please write to us at [email protected]", a domain that is currently for sale?

The app appears to claim you forgot your password once you deposit funds.
52 new verdicts were released today.

* 25 products were custodial
* 8 were closed source
* 8 were wallets but not for #Bitcoin
* 5 turned out to be no wallets at all
* 2 were vapor ware
* 1 did not support sending or receiving Bitcoin - only speculating on its value
* 1 was not released yet
* 1 was do-it-yourself
* 1 will need more investigations
Cypherock X1 joins the group of reproducible Bitcoin wallets.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vO8ajyhNfTQ


https://walletscrutiny.com/hardware/cypherockx1/
The philosophy with WalletScrutiny always was to monitor what people actually are installing and with App- and Play Store that was straight forward. A verdict was relevant for all users but with 23 verdicts associated with the same brand, it's just too complex for a user to understand even if we had the man power to assign the 23 verdicts.
In the past ten days we published **64 new wallet reviews** and another **60 updates** to verdicts.

Most of the research was done by #[0] and verified by #[1]

https://walletscrutiny.com/
Our stated mission is to look into Bitcoin Wallets and with bearer tokens like the [Opendime](https://walletscrutiny.com/bearer/opendime/) we already ventured into products that clearly are not wallets but they are meant to keep your private keys safe, so users want to know: Do they really keep you safe from loss?

Now we came across products that are marketed as "crypto vaults" but they are more akin to [password managers](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Password_manager) like LastPass - a general store of important data. By being marketed to keep your important data safe, they clear are being used for Bitcoin, too. The crypto-themed one we are looking at right now has 100k installs on Google Play.

Should we look into those or is that mission creep?