Over time I started to prefer zero/low config options with sensible defaults over manually tweaking everything myself. Fish is really great for that.

Luke Childs ☂️
Cofounder & CTO Umbrel.
Previously BitcoinJS, Browserify.
Previously BitcoinJS, Browserify.
I’m a fish maxi now
You could also do musig for payments and mint unilateral exit and only script path for user unilateral exit. Maybe that’s the best of both worlds.
Simple stateless backups and minimal onchain footprint in the optimistic best case. Worse privacy and more onchain use on the rare event that the mint disappears.
Simple stateless backups and minimal onchain footprint in the optimistic best case. Worse privacy and more onchain use on the rare event that the mint disappears.
musig leaks nothing about the contract on chain and is more block space efficient.
Using the script path for unilateral exit leaks the fact you were most likely using a Spillman channel to any observers. It’s also much larger.
Maybe simpler backups are more important to people than privacy and block space. And if that’s the case my proposal also works with the script path variant.
Using the script path for unilateral exit leaks the fact you were most likely using a Spillman channel to any observers. It’s also much larger.
Maybe simpler backups are more important to people than privacy and block space. And if that’s the case my proposal also works with the script path variant.
There are a few different ways to do Spillman channels, the way I propose requires holding onto a presigned transaction for unilateral exit. This is only needed if the mint is uncooperative. This is non deterministic so you need to store it alongside your seed. However unlike lightning if you lose it the mint can’t cheat you out of any money by settling a bad state.
You can make the users unilateral exit path deterministic by implementing it as a timelocked script path instead of a timelocked presigned transaction. Then you only need your seed and nothing else to unilaterally exit.
However I like the presigned tx model better since it results in everything being a musig spend.
You can make the users unilateral exit path deterministic by implementing it as a timelocked script path instead of a timelocked presigned transaction. Then you only need your seed and nothing else to unilaterally exit.
However I like the presigned tx model better since it results in everything being a musig spend.