baffles the mind the things that must be said today

Neal
Author of “Modern Chains.”
Catholic. Husband. Father of three.
Former Army Officer, AH-64 Pilot.
BS in Art, Literature and Philosophy from the US Military Academy.
MA in Philosophy from Holy Apostles College and Seminary.
Catholic. Husband. Father of three.
Former Army Officer, AH-64 Pilot.
BS in Art, Literature and Philosophy from the US Military Academy.
MA in Philosophy from Holy Apostles College and Seminary.
Why I’m Runnint BIP 110.
https://blossom.primal.net/f7f51bab4f0f5cee1885422674aa34…
https://blossom.primal.net/f7f51bab4f0f5cee1885422674aa34…
the “fork now” idea betrays the posture of superiority.
people are organizing and planning according to 110s schedule.
Never interrupt your enemy when they are making a mistake
vs
Quick you better make a mistake right now!
the dust will settle soon enough lol
people are organizing and planning according to 110s schedule.
Never interrupt your enemy when they are making a mistake
vs
Quick you better make a mistake right now!
the dust will settle soon enough lol
The main point of my advocacy is showing people that the money isn’t broken.
the title of that book has sent people down the wrong path in terms of advocacy.
macro is noise.
ignores the essence of money.
majoring in the minors
describes when u need prescription
economics is gay if you don’t understand the ethics it derives from
the title of that book has sent people down the wrong path in terms of advocacy.
macro is noise.
ignores the essence of money.
majoring in the minors
describes when u need prescription
economics is gay if you don’t understand the ethics it derives from
I’m not numb, as in there is a feeling there that is being snuffed out.
i am happy to be free, to be outside of fiat.
on a bitcoin standard, im always better off. either my savings power is ripping or my purchasing power.
thats the best thing about being on a btc standard. subsume the. volatility. make it yours.
you can’t do that if you think of btc as an investment. that’s still using a fiat dollar denominator.
i am happy to be free, to be outside of fiat.
on a bitcoin standard, im always better off. either my savings power is ripping or my purchasing power.
thats the best thing about being on a btc standard. subsume the. volatility. make it yours.
you can’t do that if you think of btc as an investment. that’s still using a fiat dollar denominator.
I could not agree more with you.
That’s the whole bitcoin game: serving one’s self interest.
I asked for your counsel because I saw that you were advocating for people not to run knots, not to run BIP110, so you are already in the persuasion game, you are already trying to convince others.
Just being real man, it is a little on the nose to hear you say "I'm not going to try and convince you" after I just got done reading your entire blog post trying to convince me.
I am a moral philosopher. that is literally my profession.
I do nothing but study and write about “what ought one do?”
There is nothing wrong with persuading others through rational dialog.
I am interested in the principles behind your logic and actions because I know I get a lot of things wrong, so I am constantly revalidating my thought process, asking what am I missing? The best way I have found to deal with my blindspots is to steelman every possible position I am aware of, and then pit them against each other.
Of all the contentious issues I've used this method for, this one is the most lopsided, no pun intended.
I am about to spin up my new node. I was running core v28 on an old laptop and never upgraded it, but that just seems like non-participation now because we signal our self interest with our actions. Like bitcoin is going left or right, there is no pause, tick tock next block.
So help me steelman the case for increasing the amount of arbitrary data per transaction. I cannot make a good affirmative case for why I should run the latest version of core, why I should reject BIP110.
I guess this was my final hail mary heave to make sure I'm not making a mistake in serving my interests as a bitcoiner.
That’s the whole bitcoin game: serving one’s self interest.
I asked for your counsel because I saw that you were advocating for people not to run knots, not to run BIP110, so you are already in the persuasion game, you are already trying to convince others.
Just being real man, it is a little on the nose to hear you say "I'm not going to try and convince you" after I just got done reading your entire blog post trying to convince me.
I am a moral philosopher. that is literally my profession.
I do nothing but study and write about “what ought one do?”
There is nothing wrong with persuading others through rational dialog.
I am interested in the principles behind your logic and actions because I know I get a lot of things wrong, so I am constantly revalidating my thought process, asking what am I missing? The best way I have found to deal with my blindspots is to steelman every possible position I am aware of, and then pit them against each other.
Of all the contentious issues I've used this method for, this one is the most lopsided, no pun intended.
I am about to spin up my new node. I was running core v28 on an old laptop and never upgraded it, but that just seems like non-participation now because we signal our self interest with our actions. Like bitcoin is going left or right, there is no pause, tick tock next block.
So help me steelman the case for increasing the amount of arbitrary data per transaction. I cannot make a good affirmative case for why I should run the latest version of core, why I should reject BIP110.
I guess this was my final hail mary heave to make sure I'm not making a mistake in serving my interests as a bitcoiner.
My roommate from school wrote that. I think no matter what our background is in, there is something we already use that we can relate to AI with.
It doesn’t have to be mysterious or scary, too big or too small.
see it for what it is clearly
It doesn’t have to be mysterious or scary, too big or too small.
see it for what it is clearly
yeah, you correctly articulated our misalignment.
which i have always aspired to be able to do with my friends: to pinpoint an exact premise we go different ways with.
i, like nprofile1qqsvgd5v2… pointed out, think there is a circularity of reason which contradicts itself in thinking truth is a byproduct of an empirical instantiation.
But i’m compelled by the Thomistic arguments that act has primacy to potency, form to matter, the immaterial to the material.
if i were not, then i would probably agree with you 🤣
🤜🤛
which i have always aspired to be able to do with my friends: to pinpoint an exact premise we go different ways with.
i, like nprofile1qqsvgd5v2… pointed out, think there is a circularity of reason which contradicts itself in thinking truth is a byproduct of an empirical instantiation.
But i’m compelled by the Thomistic arguments that act has primacy to potency, form to matter, the immaterial to the material.
if i were not, then i would probably agree with you 🤣
🤜🤛
Bro the play is obvious.
Capture the convexity premium embedded in the term structure of leveraged synthetic duration swaps.
Rehypothecate the collateral, tranche the exposure, arbitrage the forward curve, and roll the carry into a delta-neutral basis trade.
Then lever the mezzanine tranche, hedge the volatility skew, and warehouse the tail risk in an off-balance-sheet vehicle.
Boom. Cash money.
Capture the convexity premium embedded in the term structure of leveraged synthetic duration swaps.
Rehypothecate the collateral, tranche the exposure, arbitrage the forward curve, and roll the carry into a delta-neutral basis trade.
Then lever the mezzanine tranche, hedge the volatility skew, and warehouse the tail risk in an off-balance-sheet vehicle.
Boom. Cash money.
Brown University puts total cost to 8 trillion.
Even at 2.5, the absurdity 🤦♂️
Even at 2.5, the absurdity 🤦♂️
by you logic, every change to bitcoins protocol rules were impossible, because “less than 50% of the node runners” were using the software at some point 🤣
incentives are colliding, that’s how bitcoin arbitrates contention.
the dust must settle before anyone can say “what consensus has formed”
incentives are colliding, that’s how bitcoin arbitrates contention.
the dust must settle before anyone can say “what consensus has formed”
lol
this retard doesnt conflate personal preference with protocol consensus
🤣
this retard doesnt conflate personal preference with protocol consensus
🤣
I agree with basically every premise you describe, i think your conclusion is a step too far.
“then money is not something humans simply create and apply.”
If no people, then no money.
Without a subject, there is no aim, and value-as-such is not intelligible.
“then money is not something humans simply create and apply.”
If no people, then no money.
Without a subject, there is no aim, and value-as-such is not intelligible.
I’m at the point where I realize bitcoin doesn’t change anything about who you are, it just reveals the truth of your nature. It enables you to be all that you are. The most potent version of yourself.
Yes, you act differently, look differently, but that potential was always inside. Your light was bright, it was just covered up by debasement.
Yes, you act differently, look differently, but that potential was always inside. Your light was bright, it was just covered up by debasement.
Some thoughts:
I think BTC treasury companies are an excellent example for why it’s important to think deeply on principles and understand the ethical distinctions with high fidelity in order to avoid financial catastrophe.
Every choice comes at the cost of another, and i think anchoring our thoughts to opportunity cost are helpful.
Is there anything wrong with a company having BTC on its balance sheet?
No, of course not.
Ultimately, the world on a bitcoin standard has every person, company, entity and government denominating all in bitcoin.
Is there anything wrong with a company offering various financial products to customers?
No, not inherently. Provided disclosures are legit and there is no fraud or deceit. Offer whatever products you can to the market.
So we know there is nothing wrong with a company holding bitcoin and there is nothing wrong with offering the market a product.
Where then, is the ethical line that we get into trouble with when crossed?
I think we approach this line when we start talking about investing in companies.
You aren’t buying bitcoin.
You aren’t buying a product.
You are buying a speculative value proposition.
Regardless of the company, investing is risky.
As a bitcoiner, i understand saving in bitcoin is not risky.
Unfortunately, I think many of these pure play BTC treasury companies have been articulating their value proposition as if investing in their company is the same as saving in bitcoin.. except better.
And that is not true.
I don’t exactly how in this inevitably messy transition from fiat to bitcoin, if there is backwash or not from leveraging one system to against another.
Who is trojan horsing who? 🤷♂️
Both.
I fully accept that there is a tug of war taking place.
For the best I can articulate this dynamic:
I would say the 0 to 1 play Saylor did with MSTR did a great deal of good for adoption and helped the bitcoin cause.
I would also say there is a line somewhere between 1 and many that the play works against bitcoin.
It’s definately not a universal good.
I respect Saylor because I’ve heard him say most people should just buy bitcoin, and if they have specific needs for his products, buy his products, and if they value him and trust him, invest in his company.
I don’t respect the treasury companies that aren’t as clear.
I think BTC treasury companies are an excellent example for why it’s important to think deeply on principles and understand the ethical distinctions with high fidelity in order to avoid financial catastrophe.
Every choice comes at the cost of another, and i think anchoring our thoughts to opportunity cost are helpful.
Is there anything wrong with a company having BTC on its balance sheet?
No, of course not.
Ultimately, the world on a bitcoin standard has every person, company, entity and government denominating all in bitcoin.
Is there anything wrong with a company offering various financial products to customers?
No, not inherently. Provided disclosures are legit and there is no fraud or deceit. Offer whatever products you can to the market.
So we know there is nothing wrong with a company holding bitcoin and there is nothing wrong with offering the market a product.
Where then, is the ethical line that we get into trouble with when crossed?
I think we approach this line when we start talking about investing in companies.
You aren’t buying bitcoin.
You aren’t buying a product.
You are buying a speculative value proposition.
Regardless of the company, investing is risky.
As a bitcoiner, i understand saving in bitcoin is not risky.
Unfortunately, I think many of these pure play BTC treasury companies have been articulating their value proposition as if investing in their company is the same as saving in bitcoin.. except better.
And that is not true.
I don’t exactly how in this inevitably messy transition from fiat to bitcoin, if there is backwash or not from leveraging one system to against another.
Who is trojan horsing who? 🤷♂️
Both.
I fully accept that there is a tug of war taking place.
For the best I can articulate this dynamic:
I would say the 0 to 1 play Saylor did with MSTR did a great deal of good for adoption and helped the bitcoin cause.
I would also say there is a line somewhere between 1 and many that the play works against bitcoin.
It’s definately not a universal good.
I respect Saylor because I’ve heard him say most people should just buy bitcoin, and if they have specific needs for his products, buy his products, and if they value him and trust him, invest in his company.
I don’t respect the treasury companies that aren’t as clear.
Yeah, “by design” points at the deliberate nature of the action. ie. it’s not an accident.
It could be for good or bad intent, makes no difference.
The example I use in my book to demonstrate this is:
imagine you are sleeping and wake to find yourself handcuffed to the bed.
It doesn’t matter if was a playful partner or a malicious intruder, you know with absolute certainty that that act of handcuffing your was not an accident.
It’s “by design”
It could be for good or bad intent, makes no difference.
The example I use in my book to demonstrate this is:
imagine you are sleeping and wake to find yourself handcuffed to the bed.
It doesn’t matter if was a playful partner or a malicious intruder, you know with absolute certainty that that act of handcuffing your was not an accident.
It’s “by design”
The money is not broken; it is working as designed.
https://blossom.primal.net/3c9b61f6be8c0645a0004c69e970b8…
It is tempting to look at a chart of soup prices holding steady for seventy years, then exploding after 1971, and think, “Ah, money was working, then it broke.”
But that framing misses the essence.
When Nixon severed the dollar’s tether to gold, he removed central banking’s last constraint: reality itself.
As a store of value, fiat did not spring a leak; an extractive siphon was built into every dollar by design.
If the problem were merely a leak, if the money were simply broken, then we could fix it by tightening policy.
But the seeming “leak” is the design; the extraction is mechanical.
Fiat money must expand to survive because it is lent into existence at interest.
If the supply ever stopped growing, the system would implode: every debt chasing the same fixed pool of dollars.
That is why nprofile1qy2hwumn8… is exactly right: “Nothing stops this train.”
Monetary expansion is not a policy error; it is a mathematical necessity of debt-based money.
So when soup prices soar after 1971, it is not because something broke; it is because the mask came off.
For decades before that, central banks had been quietly issuing more paper claims to gold than gold existed.
When foreign nations called the bluff, the United States simply stopped pretending.
We were playing a gold-backed paper game with the world, and when the truth was about to surface, we flipped the table and said, “What are you going to do about it?”
Tragically, the world, to include the American people, answered, “Nothing.”
Gold’s physicality gives it a natural centralizing gravity, and centralization requires trust.
To store and exchange value at scale, we had to trust that the bankers’ gold-backed IOUs were fully redeemable for real gold in the vaults.
To think fallible men could perfectly resist the temptation to paper over short-term economic pain is laughable.
1971 proved, beyond question, that claims on gold exceeded the gold itself.
Otherwise, there would have been no need to flip the table.
Fiat merely formalized the fraud that was already underway, and necessitated constant debasement.
Since that day, productivity and wages have parted ways because the creation of money was no longer tied to the creation of value.
This is what nprofile1qythwue69… 's chart shows:
Working hard, producing more value in the world, was no longer a viable strategy for accumulating wealth.
Under fiat, the best strategy is to print the money, or fight for proximity to those who do.
https://blossom.primal.net/d5afc51db304f9dca8b3680daad993…
This is where nprofile1qy2hwumn8… is wrong; the money is not broken.
It is doing the only thing it was built to do: expand endlessly, extract silently, and transfer the fruits of human work to those nearest the source of issuance.
We all want relief from the pain of debasement, but “repairing” fiat is impossible.
The only way to solve debasement is to solve the problem of trusting fallible men.
That is what Satoshi solved for, in his own words.
That is why Bitcoin matters.
In summary:
The dollar did not “break” in 1971; fiat revealed central banking.
Fiat is not leaking value; its design necessitates debasement.
Money lent into existence at interest must either expand or collapse.
Gold hid the fraud behind trust; fiat ended the pretense and made it explicit.
The monetary system is not broken; it functions exactly as designed.
It works too well, and that is the moral problem.
https://blossom.primal.net/3c9b61f6be8c0645a0004c69e970b8…
It is tempting to look at a chart of soup prices holding steady for seventy years, then exploding after 1971, and think, “Ah, money was working, then it broke.”
But that framing misses the essence.
When Nixon severed the dollar’s tether to gold, he removed central banking’s last constraint: reality itself.
As a store of value, fiat did not spring a leak; an extractive siphon was built into every dollar by design.
If the problem were merely a leak, if the money were simply broken, then we could fix it by tightening policy.
But the seeming “leak” is the design; the extraction is mechanical.
Fiat money must expand to survive because it is lent into existence at interest.
If the supply ever stopped growing, the system would implode: every debt chasing the same fixed pool of dollars.
That is why nprofile1qy2hwumn8… is exactly right: “Nothing stops this train.”
Monetary expansion is not a policy error; it is a mathematical necessity of debt-based money.
So when soup prices soar after 1971, it is not because something broke; it is because the mask came off.
For decades before that, central banks had been quietly issuing more paper claims to gold than gold existed.
When foreign nations called the bluff, the United States simply stopped pretending.
We were playing a gold-backed paper game with the world, and when the truth was about to surface, we flipped the table and said, “What are you going to do about it?”
Tragically, the world, to include the American people, answered, “Nothing.”
Gold’s physicality gives it a natural centralizing gravity, and centralization requires trust.
To store and exchange value at scale, we had to trust that the bankers’ gold-backed IOUs were fully redeemable for real gold in the vaults.
To think fallible men could perfectly resist the temptation to paper over short-term economic pain is laughable.
1971 proved, beyond question, that claims on gold exceeded the gold itself.
Otherwise, there would have been no need to flip the table.
Fiat merely formalized the fraud that was already underway, and necessitated constant debasement.
Since that day, productivity and wages have parted ways because the creation of money was no longer tied to the creation of value.
This is what nprofile1qythwue69… 's chart shows:
Working hard, producing more value in the world, was no longer a viable strategy for accumulating wealth.
Under fiat, the best strategy is to print the money, or fight for proximity to those who do.
https://blossom.primal.net/d5afc51db304f9dca8b3680daad993…
This is where nprofile1qy2hwumn8… is wrong; the money is not broken.
It is doing the only thing it was built to do: expand endlessly, extract silently, and transfer the fruits of human work to those nearest the source of issuance.
We all want relief from the pain of debasement, but “repairing” fiat is impossible.
The only way to solve debasement is to solve the problem of trusting fallible men.
That is what Satoshi solved for, in his own words.
That is why Bitcoin matters.
In summary:
The dollar did not “break” in 1971; fiat revealed central banking.
Fiat is not leaking value; its design necessitates debasement.
Money lent into existence at interest must either expand or collapse.
Gold hid the fraud behind trust; fiat ended the pretense and made it explicit.
The monetary system is not broken; it functions exactly as designed.
It works too well, and that is the moral problem.
I agree with you we need to speak level 1, I just think we swapped the lvls.
What I took from Aristotle and Aquinas is that moral recognition is easier than economic calculation.
I think asking someone to recognize evil is more level 1 and asking someone to understand macro is more level 2.
Could be wrong, but I think selling a product that everyone needs but no one buys is evidence our sales pitch sucks.
I think when we speak economics we make it harder for the normie, and my thesis is sacrificing the macro for the moral is how we orange pill the masses.
What I took from Aristotle and Aquinas is that moral recognition is easier than economic calculation.
I think asking someone to recognize evil is more level 1 and asking someone to understand macro is more level 2.
Could be wrong, but I think selling a product that everyone needs but no one buys is evidence our sales pitch sucks.
I think when we speak economics we make it harder for the normie, and my thesis is sacrificing the macro for the moral is how we orange pill the masses.
I understand why the “broken” rhetoric caught fire, but it’s just not true.
nprofile1qqst5teef… and I discuss this topic on his last episode.
https://fountain.fm/show/2oJTnUm5VKs3xmSVdf5n
https://blossom.primal.net/e73b7dbff89a5f8bb79d93f0ba04c0…
nprofile1qqst5teef… and I discuss this topic on his last episode.
https://fountain.fm/show/2oJTnUm5VKs3xmSVdf5n
https://blossom.primal.net/e73b7dbff89a5f8bb79d93f0ba04c0…
Great conversation with nprofile1qqst5teef… Was an honor.
So grateful so many amazing bitcoiners like Daniel came before me to make the learning process smooth and effecient.
https://fountain.fm/episode/GbE7Us559aG9FBNLAQFM
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/once-bitten-a-bitco…
So grateful so many amazing bitcoiners like Daniel came before me to make the learning process smooth and effecient.
https://fountain.fm/episode/GbE7Us559aG9FBNLAQFM
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/once-bitten-a-bitco…
I run to escape 🤣
limits define what is and what is not.
Without the distinction between this and that, we cannot be anything.
Without the distinction between this and that, we cannot be anything.
music to my ears
makes sense
I get what you’re saying.
I guess I just think of buying bitcoin as an act of building itself.
Building can happen in parallel to destruction type of thing.
I guess I just think of buying bitcoin as an act of building itself.
Building can happen in parallel to destruction type of thing.
Sucks that it wasn’t enough to save him :(
whatever was on exchanges? if it all stays on coinbase accounts, that wouldn’t show up onchain, correct?
only if people moved to cold storage or something, if i understand how the exchanges work technically
only if people moved to cold storage or something, if i understand how the exchanges work technically
To feel validated with the rip or unsure with the dip, just posted indicates a lack of understanding.
The problem with the money printer is a particular moral crime and its formal slavery. 🫡


