X.KOJIRA.IO
Timeline

2o

npub150rlcxha3efsleq762eawgaxmry8cjtnms63t7ucp9v8v45zwmsq59d063
I think it's not so much that, it's more a fundamental cake and eat it to situation with regard to what is actually being attempted here. You cannot have stateful and stateless at once, managed and unmanaged, and if you try then every release will have a critical issue, you're simply shifting critical issues around.
She's not wrong
I'm curious how you see the UX for this. How to make clear that a fork has happened, and to who, and what options to give them in response, and so on.
> In a Nostr setup where relays are used purely for message delivery, MLS group forks are, in theory, hard to avoid.

This is a very important point. You have MLS trying to enforce an identical shared history and nostr trying to enforce discrete, redundant portability.
Don't fret, I'll be alright. Your flat earth theory on the other hand...
This is all just rambling.

Go look at how your math brought you to 170 (and not 169 or 171). That path has been shattered by recent real-world results. You can posit a higher number for this "universal speed limit", or a range, but you cannot stick with 170.

Your "for one hour" is not even relevant here, smoke and mirrors. Adding a time assumption does nothing when lower-level assumptions on which your theory absolutely relies have been categorically proven false.
The one trying to prove something is you, with your fundamental limit theory. Those results *disprove* your theory, conclusively.

Pretty simple here. Your theory relies, in absolute terms, on assumptions that have been categorically disproven by experiment. In terms of junking a theory this is about as clear cut as it gets.
You don't need any of that to junk this theory.

Under your assumptions, the error rate for the logical qubit has to *always be worse* than the physical qubit, no matter how good the isolation is. Always. Every single time. No two ways about it.

Also the lifetime of the logical qubit would have to always be shorter.

For your theory to have any legs, it would be impossible for an experiment to demonstrate, at any scale, that this is not *always* the case.

However experiments have already demonstrated that this is not always the case. Those results prove irrefutably that N is *not* the governing factor in these QEC systems.

Simply, with your math you could never have a logical qubit outperform a physical one. Since we have seen that already, the 170 qubit ceiling is clearly an arbitrary hurdle and not a wall.

It's flat earth now, you should drop that number. Not even the hardcore sceptics are reckless enough to argue in that direction.
sounds to me like he's exhausted
three years of work he put in to this direction, now everything moves in a hash direction and, and if we're being honest to get any sort of hash-based decentralised transcoding system working for users protocol wide (or anything even near protocol wide) is another two or three years.
building on nostr is fast. propagation on nostr is incredibly slow.
I'm not talking about Damus getting complicated, I'm talking about nostr getting complicated.
All-bunker-nostr plus don't-follow-people-only-follow-relays nostr.
Trying bunker and extension only, let's see how we go.