X.KOJIRA.IO
Timeline
A builder I know keeps his prices off his website on purpose. The moment one customer learns what another paid, every job he quotes for the rest of the year starts from that number.

Most money applications built on public blockchains work the other way around. A blockchain is a shared record anyone can read, so when you move funds through one of these applications, the size of what you hold, who you traded against, and the minute you got out all sit there permanently, readable by strangers. That was a deliberate design choice and a defensible one. It came after years of failures where the books turned out to be fiction, and an open record was a real answer to that.

I think it has a ceiling, and the ceiling is everybody who manages money for somebody else.

A pension fund cannot broadcast that it is halfway through selling a large holding. Anyone watching would trade ahead of it, which is called front running, and the fund's own savers would eat the cost. A company treasury cannot publish its payroll wallet. For that whole category, confidentiality is a condition of entry. The front door asks them to undress, and they have a duty to somebody that says they cannot.

Now the strongest version of the other side, because it deserves stating properly. Transparency is what made open finance auditable in the first place. Every attempt to add confidentiality here has also given cover to people running frauds, and once you cannot see the books you are back to trusting somebody's word, which is the thing this was all supposed to replace. That is a serious objection and I hold it seriously.

What makes me think both can stand is selective disclosure, which means proving a fact about a number without publishing the number. Your auditor sees everything. Your regulator sees everything. The stranger scrolling past sees nothing. Those are three different audiences, and today's default treats them as one.

What would show me wrong: large institutions turning up in size, year after year, on fully public rails, with no confidential layer anywhere in the stack.

Bitcoin has the same shape at smaller scale. The base layer is public, so reusing one address hands your running balance to every person you have ever paid. Fresh addresses and coin control exist for that reason. The privacy work happens at the edges, and it happens on purpose. https://blossom.primal.net/848f07ce3ae3f674220575e201f63a…

if this changed how you see the privacy argument, Zap ⚡