X.KOJIRA.IO
Timeline
Dug
[email protected] · npub1zrmu0amjmkynxlxgmdsyrjmp8vhxdz8ch5vja9vh9ym4natg8k5s8ge9wx

Bitcoin and Capital Gains

As the third piece with the same title, bitcoin and capital  gains taxes are topics that continue to play on my mind. Having been right royally skewered in the past from dividend, share sales and not least having to pay capital gains on the incredibly meagre 1.6% annual return on my first house (one year on and it still causes discomfort), it is a topic that requires thought. I pay sufficient tax to keep me out of jail (although very few people actually go to jail for tax evasion it appears), HMRC still sent a notice of enquiry, and my accountant still charge a lot of money. I don’t want to pay more taxes than I have to, which it why my previous two pieces have been oriented around using loans to help people reduce the need to sell their bitcoin, so reducing their tax bill.

But saying this, as my work has continued to evolve (social capital and bitcoin), this was not a “never sell, hodl forever” mentality, as I still recommended a spend and replace strategy to continue supporting bitcoin entrepreneurs and their businesses. Fortunately for me, for the time being at least, I’m attempting the live within my means, meaning that while (recent pumps aside), we continue to be in a bear market, I’m not having to sell to cover expenses. As a result, there is no need for me to take out a bitcoin backed loan, although the opportunity is still there if an unexpected expense emerged or maybe required, if, for example, I was to a) jump ship from my current employer or b) get nudged out for my views not being suitably DEI aligned (another Nostr Read, why so serious?).

As my previous pieces outlined, while there are a range of products with new ones being added all the time, that protect one from liquidation, following the mapping of parts of the suitcoin and BIP-110 battle lines, some new risks/perspectives began to emerge. With this new clarity, while the risks of corporate capture of the protocol with the bitcoin consortium may remain present, combined with everyone’s newfound interest in entropy, attention may have been carefully diverted from personal sovereignty. Why risk poorly audited code within a hardware wallet, when you could simply hold your coins on Coinbase? If not that, how’s about some collaborative custody with Swan Vault or for the really careful, high net worth crew; Anchorwatch, who have been doing a fine marketing campaign identifying limitations with all manner of open-source repositories? For my conspiratorial lizard brain, the release of the news of the consortium, with the failed soft-fork AND the timing of Coldcard hack felt a little too perfect, was there was a concerted effort to dissuade people from holding their coins in singlesig wallet (Nick Neuman would suggest you basically need multisig to buy anything more expensive than a coffee). I’m not going to profess to be the individual sovereignty maximalists I’d like to be, but I too was considering moving at least a portion of my coins into an ETF for safe keeping (and diversity) if nothing else. The morning of the 31st of July certainly helped bring focus on how reliant I was on a small Canadian hardware manufacturer, individual sovereignty versus single point of failure was a real trade-off was still present in my setup.

Looking at the above sketch, the divide between those attempting to financialise and fiatize bitcoin can be appreciated, with those towards the left tending to favour institutional money, while those on the right wanted bitcoin to remain more with the users. This is a huge simplification of the situation, but even those influencers upon the left appeared keener to emphasise the risks associated with any change, with less attention on the co-option reducing what may have initially attracted them to the asset (separating money and state). As Thomas Paccio once said on What Bitcoin Did, “if bitcoin fails, we’ll all be rich and depressed”, if the institutions get their way, each bitcoin could be worth millions, but we will only be able to spend them after the have taken out credit on top of the bitcoin and use their payment rails. From this observation, whether it is those issuing equities to purchase bitcoin, or Blackrock, Fidelity, or Coinbase who may follow Strategy’s lead by offering bitcoin backed yield on funds held with them. Following on from this, companies such as Blackrock offering in kind swaps for you to move your bitcoin into their carefully managed ETF wrapper, the on-ramps for taking bitcoin out of self-custody are getting more seamless by the week. The “rich and depressed” timeline feels closer than many think.

Now, for me, while on the face of it, these big institutions are welcoming you with open arms, to save you from your own recklessness of holding your own keys, as the great taking tells us, in times of financial disruption, those assets held by a custodian are not actually yours. Bitcoin was released at a time when “Chanceller [was] on brink of second bailout”, it was designed to protect the individual from being devalued but also protect the individual from a bail-in, as was the case in Cyprus. We can sing and dance all day about the power these institutions have or don’t have, and how BIP-110 was always destined to fail, but if we willingly hand over our assets to the parties whispering in the ears of government, we cannot complain when we are left fixing a leaking roof in a house that is no longer ours (Thanks Guy). Or to put the analogy slightly more in the bitcoin context, being left looking at a bitcoin balance on a screen of a hardfork your custodian decided they would give you.

But, hopefully, at least a small portion of the readers are not so easily fooled to listen to all these snake oil sales people, offering security, safety, consistent yield, tax efficient return of capital income, when there is nothing of substance. This is not bitcoin, this is selling ownership of the harder asset for claims and income in a softer asset, so what is to be done when someone needs income and maybe it is not the best time to sell you bitcoin at 50% off the all time high? And this is where we circle back to the bitcoin backed loans, if done right, you can access liquidity to cover unexpected expenses or simply living expenses without incurring capital gains, and maybe once prices rises, you can sell less bitcoin to repay the loan. Mark Mossspeaks very eloquently about this practice; it’s what the rich do, they hold assets, they borrow, keep the assets and then borrow some more. But saying that, Mark is very experienced, and this is usual practice of family offices with expertise in this area and experience doing this. For a 70IQ bitcoiner “who got lucky”, this could be the equivalent of a preapproved credit card at 18 years old, where they put up a portion of their stack and get the cash they always wanted to buy their dream car. In this scenario, the carefully accumulated bitcoin stack, irrespective of the lender’s intent, has a) been exposed to the fiat system and b) had the ownership (even partially), transferred to another party, while also printing fiat out of fresh air to issue the cash.

For the eagle eared amongst you, I would recommend listening clearly to the next ad read as you make your way through this week’s 40 hours of podcasts. What side of bitcoin do the sponsors sit? Big bitcoin, with the institutional partners and institutional custody (Anchorwatch, ArchInvest, Epoch Ventures?), or those lesser known names where you might believe that the podcast host actually uses their products (h/t easydns and @cbp), rather than simply grabbing the cash. Within this spectrum of podcast sponsorship deals, names appear and then fall by the wayside, with the Coldcard hack providing a rather unpleasant example of the hosts using the product but not always using them correctly (Len of CBP being part of a minority). An interesting observation was Ledn’s presence across a range of podcasts, both on the corporate side but also in the middle ground. While having Tether and Coinbase ventures as investors, they don’t appear to be quite so aligned with bitcoin’s corporate blob, even if the very nature of their business requires them to be integrated into the fiat system (issuing fiat). Mauricio has a really interesting back story, but as with my previous work on bitcoin and capital gains, careful consideration is needed before taking out a loan against your bitcoin, with a clear road map for either repaying or refinancing it sometime in the future.

As the risks associated with bitcoin-based loans being margin called or companies issuing those loans going bust reduces, care is still needed before relinquishing allodial ownership of your bitcoin to a third party. Ledn (and others including Strike) appear to be in the process of reaching product market fit, which will only get clearer as the rates of loans continue to reduce (as they can access the bond market, as Ledn has recently). But in a similar way to Strategy or Coinbase custody becoming an ever-greater honey pot for a government’s future Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, the same could be said about these loan operators. For those who may not have been scared away from self-custody by the Coldcard hack, and have not handed their keys directly to Uncle Larry and friends, they may have taken the prudent, tax efficient approach of taking a loan. Now imagine 5 to 10 years into the future, bitcoin having engaged in a calm 30% CAGR (~$185-689k), at which point, there could be a DRAMATIC amount of outstanding loans against the average Hodler’s stack. With the necessary agreements and approvals to have so much liquidity associated with these loans, there will likely be serious players integrated into this eco-system. In this situation, rather than a government openly nationalised companies holding large quantities of bitcoin, market volatility could be utilised to liquidate loans so draw previously self-custodied bitcoin into the hands of institutions and so the government.

Again, this could be viewed as rather conspiratorial, and the companies offering loans could be providing services their customers want and value. However, whether it is handing over custody to a third party or taking out a fiat loan against your bitcoin, risks are introduced, where the outcome could be the individual ending up holding less or no bitcoin. In this situation, it is not the large corporate holder, wanting to make bitcoin the pristine capital of a new fiat age, but a smaller company offering a service to make a bitcoin holder’s life a little easier, if nothing else in relation to calculating taxes. Unless this process is carefully managed, the net result will be negative, firstly to some individuals, but if an event (potentially manufactured) led to mass liquidations of collateral, to bitcoin holders more broadly. If in this case, the fewer individuals holding their bitcoin themselves, able to trade, peer to peer, outside government approval, potentially purchasing products that government doesn’t approve of (such as raw milk), the eco-system of bitcoin would be weaker.

This is not financial advice, I’m not a financial advisor, I’m also not as familiar with such family office behaviours as leveraging assets to borrow against them, but as a relatively humble sat stacker, I’m feeling more comfortable in my position. Having listened to a @danielprince podcast a while ago, the idea of SELLING some bitcoin at the top of the market to buy a fun sport car (or another suitably extravagant purchase) and then hoping the car’s depreciation is less than the fall in bitcoin value plus any capital gains incurred to then buyback to bitcoin that was originally sold. While presented as slightly frivolous, there is method to my madness; if it is a carefully considered purchase, worth a sale of bitcoin, the purchased car should hold its value. The other side of this is when the value of your bitcoin stack is lower and you may not want to sell, in this case, you could buy the car by taking out a loan (bitcoin backed or not), with the aim of selling some bitcoin once the price is higher to cover the difference between the car’s depreciation and any outstanding loan.

Within either scenario, it appears useful to be aware of the risks associated with either path, holding your own bitcoin, taking out a loan, exposing coins to the fiat system or handing over custody of coins. Each may have benefits, each has drawback, careful consideration will help you make better choices. Within this, following the Coldcard attack, there may be a need to return to your own set up and review your understanding of whether you were lucky to get through it with your coins intact, unlucky to have lost coins, or your set-up was fit for purpose. In my view, being scared into the warm embrace of an institutional custodian, away from sovereignty feels slightly too perfect an outcome for those larger players. The resistance for de minimis exemption then backs people into the arms of bitcoin-backed loan providers, representing some half-way house of custody, because let’s be honest, while backing a loan, you really can’t be selling those coins. But unless you are someone really comfortable with such things, maybe use the loan to bridge a gap, purchasing something important with the aim of pay it off in a more bitcoin efficient way.

Whether it is through offering you Bitcoin IOUs or persuading you to relinquish custody to access liquidity, I hope this piece has built awareness of potential Wolves at the gate. Bitcoin is not a permissioned system, so if companies offer you permissioned services be wary, even if the yield and tax implications look very appealing. I really don’t like completing my taxes and particularly don’t like paying my accountant to simply put my figures into their system, only for someone from HMRC to tell me they want more information and the accountant charging me more. I worry that if I was to take out a lot of loans, this would be greater complexity for my taxes, combined with the need to continually expose parts of my stack to the fiat system, so that they know more about what I own. I’m happy to say I’m at a similar position to a previous piece, and I’m getting happier simply selling my bitcoin to purchasing things that will add value to my life. Keeping track of this is relatively straight forward and something I can get better at. If I’m confident I’ll never get around to selling what I’m buying that the moment, I don’t even have to record the cost basis of these purchases. And anyway, even in the worse case scenario of considering zero cost basis, at least for the moment, Capital gains tax is less than income tax. In this situation, I will just have to become more comfortable with spending my bitcoin, and know that I am doing my part building a future economy built on hard money and doing what the corporates don’t want me to.Bitcoin and Capital Gains: The 500lb Gorilla in the room As the third piece with the same title, bitcoin and capital gains taxes are topics that continue to play on my mind. Having been right royally skewered in the past from dividend, share sales and not least having to pay capital gains on the incredibly meagre 1.6% annual return on my first house (one year on and it still causes discomfort), it is a topic that requires thought. I pay sufficient tax to keep me out of jail (although very few people actually go to jail for tax evasion it appears), HMRC still sent a notice of enquiry, and my accountant still charge a lot of money. I don’t want to pay more taxes than I have to, which it why my previous two pieces have been oriented around using loans to help people reduce the need to sell their bitcoin, so reducing their tax bill. But saying this, as my work has continued to evolve (social capital and bitcoin), this was not a “never sell, hodl forever” mentality, as I still recommended a spend and replace strategy to continue supporting bitcoin entrepreneurs and their businesses. Fortunately for me, for the time being at least, I’m attempting the live within my means, meaning that while (recent pumps aside), we continue to be in a bear market, I’m not having to sell to cover expenses. As a result, there is no need for me to take out a bitcoin backed loan, although the opportunity is still there if an unexpected expense emerged or maybe required, if, for example, I was to a) jump ship from my current employer or b) get nudged out for my views not being suitably DEI aligned (another Nostr Read, why so serious?). As my previous pieces outlined, while there are a range of products with new ones being added all the time, that protect one from liquidation, following the mapping of parts of the suitcoin and BIP-110 battle lines, some new risks/perspectives began to emerge. With this new clarity, while the risks of corporate capture of the protocol with the bitcoin consortium may remain present, combined with everyone’s newfound interest in entropy, attention may have been carefully diverted from personal sovereignty. Why risk poorly audited code within a hardware wallet, when you could simply hold your coins on Coinbase? If not that, how’s about some collaborative custody with Swan Vault or for the really careful, high net worth crew; Anchorwatch, who have been doing a fine marketing campaign identifying limitations with all manner of open-source repositories? For my conspiratorial lizard brain, the release of the news of the consortium, with the failed soft-fork AND the timing of Coldcard hack felt a little too perfect, was there was a concerted effort to dissuade people from holding their coins in singlesig wallet (Nick Neuman would suggest you basically need multisig to buy anything more expensive than a coffee). I’m not going to profess to be the individual sovereignty maximalists I’d like to be, but I too was considering moving at least a portion of my coins into an ETF for safe keeping (and diversity) if nothing else. The morning of the 31st of July certainly helped bring focus on how reliant I was on a small Canadian hardware manufacturer, individual sovereignty versus single point of failure was a real trade-off was still present in my setup.

Looking at the above sketch, the divide between those attempting to financialise and fiatize bitcoin can be appreciated, with those towards the left tending to favour institutional money, while those on the right wanted bitcoin to remain more with the users. This is a huge simplification of the situation, but even those influencers upon the left appeared keener to emphasise the risks associated with any change, with less attention on the co-option reducing what may have initially attracted them to the asset (separating money and state). As Thomas Paccio once said on What Bitcoin Did, “if bitcoin fails, we’ll all be rich and depressed”, if the institutions get their way, each bitcoin could be worth millions, but we will only be able to spend them after the have taken out credit on top of the bitcoin and use their payment rails. From this observation, whether it is those issuing equities to purchase bitcoin, or Blackrock, Fidelity, or Coinbase who may follow Strategy’s lead by offering bitcoin backed yield on funds held with them. Following on from this, companies such as Blackrock offering in kind swaps for you to move your bitcoin into their carefully managed ETF wrapper, the on-ramps for taking bitcoin out of self-custody are getting more seamless by the week. The “rich and depressed” timeline feels closer than many think. Now, for me, while on the face of it, these big institutions are welcoming you with open arms, to save you from your own recklessness of holding your own keys, as the great taking tells us, in times of financial disruption, those assets held by a custodian are not actually yours. Bitcoin was released at a time when “Chanceller [was] on brink of second bailout”, it was designed to protect the individual from being devalued but also protect the individual from a bail-in, as was the case in Cyprus. We can sing and dance all day about the power these institutions have or don’t have, and how BIP-110 was always destined to fail, but if we willingly hand over our assets to the parties whispering in the ears of government, we cannot complain when we are left fixing a leaking roof in a house that is no longer ours (Thanks Guy). Or to put the analogy slightly more in the bitcoin context, being left looking at a bitcoin balance on a screen of a hardfork your custodian decided they would give you. But, hopefully, at least a small portion of the readers are not so easily fooled to listen to all these snake oil sales people, offering security, safety, consistent yield, tax efficient return of capital income, when there is nothing of substance. This is not bitcoin, this is selling ownership of the harder asset for claims and income in a softer asset, so what is to be done when someone needs income and maybe it is not the best time to sell you bitcoin at 50% off the all time high? And this is where we circle back to the bitcoin backed loans, if done right, you can access liquidity to cover unexpected expenses or simply living expenses without incurring capital gains, and maybe once prices rises, you can sell less bitcoin to repay the loan. Mark Moss speaks very eloquently about this practice; it’s what the rich do, they hold assets, they borrow, keep the assets and then borrow some more. But saying that, Mark is very experienced, and this is usual practice of family offices with expertise in this area and experience doing this. For a 70IQ bitcoiner “who got lucky”, this could be the equivalent of a preapproved credit card at 18 years old, where they put up a portion of their stack and get the cash they always wanted to buy their dream car. In this scenario, the carefully accumulated bitcoin stack, irrespective of the lender’s intent, has a) been exposed to the fiat system and b) had the ownership (even partially), transferred to another party, while also printing fiat out of fresh air to issue the cash.

For the eagle eared amongst you, I would recommend listening clearly to the next ad read as you make your way through this week’s 40 hours of podcasts. What side of bitcoin do the sponsors sit? Big bitcoin, with the institutional partners and institutional custody (Anchorwatch, ArchInvest, Epoch Ventures?), or those lesser known names where you might believe that the podcast host actually uses their products (h/t easydns and @cbp), rather than simply grabbing the cash. Within this spectrum of podcast sponsorship deals, names appear and then fall by the wayside, with the Coldcard hack providing a rather unpleasant example of the hosts using the product but not always using them correctly (Len of CBP being part of a minority). An interesting observation was Ledn’s presence across a range of podcasts, both on the corporate side but also in the middle ground. While having Tether and Coinbase ventures as investors, they don’t appear to be quite so aligned with bitcoin’s corporate blob, even if the very nature of their business requires them to be integrated into the fiat system (issuing fiat). Mauricio has a really interesting back story, but as with my previous work on bitcoin and capital gains, careful consideration is needed before taking out a loan against your bitcoin, with a clear road map for either repaying or refinancing it sometime in the future. As the risks associated with bitcoin-based loans being margin called or companies issuing those loans going bust reduces, care is still needed before relinquishing allodial ownership of your bitcoin to a third party. Ledn (and others including Strike) appear to be in the process of reaching product market fit, which will only get clearer as the rates of loans continue to reduce (as they can access the bond market, as Ledn has recently). But in a similar way to Strategy or Coinbase custody becoming an ever-greater honey pot for a government’s future Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, the same could be said about these loan operators. For those who may not have been scared away from self-custody by the Coldcard hack, and have not handed their keys directly to Uncle Larry and friends, they may have taken the prudent, tax efficient approach of taking a loan. Now imagine 5 to 10 years into the future, bitcoin having engaged in a calm 30% CAGR (~$185-689k), at which point, there could be a DRAMATIC amount of outstanding loans against the average Hodler’s stack. With the necessary agreements and approvals to have so much liquidity associated with these loans, there will likely be serious players integrated into this eco-system. In this situation, rather than a government openly nationalised companies holding large quantities of bitcoin, market volatility could be utilised to liquidate loans so draw previously self-custodied bitcoin into the hands of institutions and so the government. Again, this could be viewed as rather conspiratorial, and the companies offering loans could be providing services their customers want and value. However, whether it is handing over custody to a third party or taking out a fiat loan against your bitcoin, risks are introduced, where the outcome could be the individual ending up holding less or no bitcoin. In this situation, it is not the large corporate holder, wanting to make bitcoin the pristine capital of a new fiat age, but a smaller company offering a service to make a bitcoin holder’s life a little easier, if nothing else in relation to calculating taxes. Unless this process is carefully managed, the net result will be negative, firstly to some individuals, but if an event (potentially manufactured) led to mass liquidations of collateral, to bitcoin holders more broadly. If in this case, the fewer individuals holding their bitcoin themselves, able to trade, peer to peer, outside government approval, potentially purchasing products that government doesn’t approve of (such as raw milk), the eco-system of bitcoin would be weaker. This is not financial advice, I’m not a financial advisor, I’m also not as familiar with such family office behaviours as leveraging assets to borrow against them, but as a relatively humble sat stacker, I’m feeling more comfortable in my position. Having listened to a @danielprince podcast a while ago, the idea of SELLING some bitcoin at the top of the market to buy a fun sport car (or another suitably extravagant purchase) and then hoping the car’s depreciation is less than the fall in bitcoin value plus any capital gains incurred to then buyback to bitcoin that was originally sold. While presented as slightly frivolous, there is method to my madness; if it is a carefully considered purchase, worth a sale of bitcoin, the purchased car should hold its value. The other side of this is when the value of your bitcoin stack is lower and you may not want to sell, in this case, you could buy the car by taking out a loan (bitcoin backed or not), with the aim of selling some bitcoin once the price is higher to cover the difference between the car’s depreciation and any outstanding loan. Within either scenario, it appears useful to be aware of the risks associated with either path, holding your own bitcoin, taking out a loan, exposing coins to the fiat system or handing over custody of coins. Each may have benefits, each has drawback, careful consideration will help you make better choices. Within this, following the Coldcard attack, there may be a need to return to your own set up and review your understanding of whether you were lucky to get through it with your coins intact, unlucky to have lost coins, or your set-up was fit for purpose. In my view, being scared into the warm embrace of an institutional custodian, away from sovereignty feels slightly too perfect an outcome for those larger players. The resistance for de minimis exemption then backs people into the arms of bitcoin-backed loan providers, representing some half-way house of custody, because let’s be honest, while backing a loan, you really can’t be selling those coins. But unless you are someone really comfortable with such things, maybe use the loan to bridge a gap, purchasing something important with the aim of pay it off in a more bitcoin efficient way. Whether it is through offering you Bitcoin IOUs or persuading you to relinquish custody to access liquidity, I hope this piece has built awareness of potential Wolves at the gate. Bitcoin is not a permissioned system, so if companies offer you permissioned services be wary, even if the yield and tax implications look very appealing. I really don’t like completing my taxes and particularly don’t like paying my accountant to simply put my figures into their system, only for someone from HMRC to tell me they want more information and the accountant charging me more. I worry that if I was to take out a lot of loans, this would be greater complexity for my taxes, combined with the need to continually expose parts of my stack to the fiat system, so that they know more about what I own. I’m happy to say I’m at a similar position to a previous piece, and I’m getting happier simply selling my bitcoin to purchasing things that will add value to my life. Keeping track of this is relatively straight forward and something I can get better at. If I’m confident I’ll never get around to selling what I’m buying that the moment, I don’t even have to record the cost basis of these purchases. And anyway, even in the worse case scenario of considering zero cost basis, at least for the moment, Capital gains tax is less than income tax. In this situation, I will just have to become more comfortable with spending my bitcoin, and know that I am doing my part building a future economy built on hard money and doing what the corporates don’t want me to.

updated 2026-08-22 02:07 JST